Court Filing
Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 Time Speaker ████████████████████████████████████████ Note 2:23:45 PM Judge Hippler State v. Bryan Kohberger CR01-24-31665 C MN Hearings Thompson / Taylor 2:24:01 PM States Attorney Bill Thompson / Ashley Jennings / Jeff Nye 2:24:02 PM Defense Anne Taylor / Elisa Massoth Attorney 2:24:03 PM Defendant present in Custody 2:24:03 PM Judge Hippler Reviews file 2:24:15 PM will now hear agrument on the Franks Motion 2:24:47 PM argument on suppression IGG 2:24:55 PM Judge Hippler can also argue that it is wrapped up in the same issue 2:25:27 PM States Attorney no 2:25:29 PM Judge Hippler will do argument on suppression of the IGG matters and then the Franks 2:25:50 PM Defense Argument on MN to Suppress IGG matters Attorney Taylor 2:28:05 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 2:28:10 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:30:26 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel re: DNA 2:30:51 PM Defense response to court / continues argument Attorney 2:31:04 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel about if client has standing for suppression 2:31:25 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:31:51 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions 2:32:06 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:32:21 PM Judge Hippler discussion with counsel 2:32:35 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:33:25 PM Judge Hippler how is in violation of his rights 2:33:52 PM understand your position, it is not well supported in the law, 2:34:20 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 1/23/2025 1 of 6 Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 2:34:49 PM Judge Hippler trying to understand the legal argument 2:34:59 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:35:11 PM Judge Hippler comments to counsel 2:36:12 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:38:04 PM Judge Hippler specific DNA test done of the sample? 2:38:20 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:38:28 PM Judge Hippler trying to understand your position 2:38:40 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:41:21 PM Judge Hippler how is that a constitution violation? 2:41:31 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:42:19 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions counsel 2:42:29 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:43:19 PM Judge Hippler you have the burden of showing items should be suppressed 2:43:34 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:44:12 PM Judge Hippler struggle with the idea that DNA left at a crime scene, expectation of privacy, can't be searched without a warrant 2:44:51 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 2:48:58 PM States Attorney Response argument to MN to Suppress Nye 2:50:17 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel about not using the databases 2:50:32 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 2:51:18 PM Judge Hippler questions 2:51:36 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 2:53:08 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions counsel 2:53:18 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 3:03:46 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel - 1/23/2025 2 of 6 Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 3:04:10 PM States Attorney response 3:04:13 PM Defense Rebuttal argument Attorney 3:05:21 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions 3:05:28 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:05:57 PM Judge Hippler questions-how does that change the analysis on the trash pull 3:06:12 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:11:06 PM Judge Hippler will take this matter under advisement and issue a written decision 3:11:25 PM will move forward 3:11:32 PM Defense request recess Attorney 3:11:37 PM Judge Hippler back in 5 minutes 3:11:44 PM recess 3:21:45 PM back on the record 3:21:49 PM Judge Hippler take up Franks 3:21:54 PM Defense Argument on Franks Attorney 3:23:26 PM Judge Hippler with the exception of the IGG 3:23:34 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:26:41 PM DE # D2 3:39:12 PM Judge Hippler quesitons counsel 3:39:29 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:42:30 PM Judge Hippler comments to counsel 3:42:43 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:43:31 PM Judge Hippler comments 3:43:33 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:49:01 PM DE # D7 and 8 3:50:20 PM D1 B and C 3:54:55 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions counsel re: direct DNA connection PC to support 3:55:37 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 1/23/2025 3 of 6 Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 3:55:45 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 3:56:01 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:56:46 PM Judge Hippler comments to counsel on probable cause 3:58:12 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 3:59:30 PM Judge Hippler comments to counsel / questions 4:00:24 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:01:17 PM Judge Hippler matters for trial not for PC 4:01:26 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:01:47 PM Judge Hippler discussion with counsel 4:02:25 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:03:35 PM Judge Hippler DNA still on the knife sheath 4:03:44 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:04:04 PM Judge Hippler applying Franks standard, for purposes of PC, have not explained why they wouldn't have found PC as to Mr. Kohberger 4:05:03 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:07:55 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 4:08:14 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:08:29 PM Judge Hippler comments to counsel 4:09:08 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:09:34 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions 4:09:48 PM States Attorney Argument on IGG Jennings 4:14:52 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 4:15:40 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:15:57 PM Judge Hippler additional question 1/23/2025 4 of 6 Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 4:16:09 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:21:11 PM Judge Hippler comments / questions counsel 4:21:59 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:23:29 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel-relevance of statements of DM to PC 4:23:51 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:24:10 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 4:24:21 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:32:23 PM Judge Hippler questions camera shots in the affidavit 4:32:59 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:38:56 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 4:39:19 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:39:33 PM Judge Hippler imputed erroneous statements 4:39:53 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:40:30 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel 4:40:43 PM States Attorney response / cont. argument 4:46:19 PM Defense Rebuttal argument Attorney 4:47:03 PM Judge Hippler comments 4:47:07 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:48:37 PM Judge Hippler what's the omission for the misstatement as to the Amazon warrant 4:48:50 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:49:11 PM Judge Hippler material intentional or reckless statement 4:49:23 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:49:35 PM Judge Hippler questions counsel-what did they fail to disclose? 4:50:06 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 1/23/2025 5 of 6 Hippler-Meyer-Christie Valcich-01/23/2025 1A-CRT507 4:53:53 PM Judge Hippler questions the evidence they relied on Ridge Road 4:54:12 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 4:54:42 PM Judge Hippler where is it in the record? 4:54:50 PM Defense original memorandum Attorney 4:55:54 PM Judge Hippler photo but not the information that ties it to the ridge road 4:56:12 PM Defense response / cont. argument Attorney 5:00:44 PM Judge Hippler will adjourn for today 5:00:51 PM will take the matters under advisement and issue written de 5:01:08 PM Evidence on MTS tomorrow 5:01:20 PM End of Case 5:01:23 PM 5:01:23 PM 5:01:24 PM 5:01:24 PM 1/23/2025 6 of 6