State Exhibit S 8a Rebuttal Hille

Close

Court Filing

PDF State Exhibit S 8a Rebuttal HilleSurveillance Video Collection
court Court Filing Idaho 4

Named in this document

  • Bryan Kohberger Person
  • Rob Hille Person
  • Connell, WA Location
  • Floyd's Cannabis Co. Organization
  • Lewiston, ID Location
  • Main Street, Moscow Location
  • Washington State University (WSU) Organization
  • Kane Francetich Person
  • Kenny Bonnefin Person
  • Lawrence Mowery Person
  • Linda Lane, Moscow Location
  • Walmart Organization
-1 of 1-OFFICIAL RECORD FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) All Document signatures participants have have been digitally verified signed by a.

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION certified FBI information system.

Date of entry 02/02/2023 On December 24, 2022 Special Agent (SA) Hille responded to Albertsons located at 400 Bridge Street, Clarkston, Washington to collect video surveillance.

Upon arrival SA Hille was given access to the video surveillance system and collected footage from all exterior cameras as well as the entrance / exit cameras for the time period of November 13, 2022 between 12:00 p.m. and
2:00 p.m.

The video surveillance was copied onto a USB drive and was subsequently provided to Detective Lawrence Mowery of the Moscow Police Department for evidentiary storage.

Investigation on 12/24/2022 at Clarkston, Washington, United States (In Person) File # 9A-SU-3683464 Date drafted 02/02/2023 by HILLE ROB STATE'S EXHIBIT exhibitsticker.com This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned to your agency; it and its to be distributed outside your agency.

010756 S-8 (a)
CR01-24-31665

-1 of 15-OFFICIAL RECORD FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) Document participants have digitally signed.

FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION 25 certified FBI information system Date of entry 05/01/2023 Through the course of this investigation investigators performed an extensive canvas of Moscow, Idaho (ID) and the surrounding areas, to include Pullman, Washington (WA), Clarkston, WA and Lewiston, ID, for video surveillance which may have been relevant to this investigation. The surveillance which was collected was reviewed by Special Agent (SA) Hille in conjunction with other investigative leads in an attempt to identify and locate a suspect and / or suspect vehicle.

Through this surveillance review and a review of other investigative leads a suspect vehicle identified as a 2011 2016 white Hyundai Elantra (hereafter referred to as " Vehicle 1 "). Additionally, a subject was identified as Bryan KOHBERGER.

The following is intended to be a summary of the collected surveillance footage, highlighting pertinent sightings, which appear to show vehicles matching the description of Vehicle 1 or sightings of individuals matching The description of KOHBERGER on November 13, 2023.

The below noted camera locations were checked for their time stamp accuracy as compared to actual current time. The following time accuracy was found for each location:
787 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho Camera time accurate to local time.

763 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho Camera time accurate to local time.

755 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho Camera time accurate to local time.

1311 S Main Street, Moscow, ID Camera time approximately one minute and 43 seconds behind local time.

1125 Ridge Road, Apt 108, Moscow, ID Camera time accurate to local time.

1320 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID, 1320 Dumpster Camera time approximately five seconds behind local time.

1112 King Road, Moscow, ID Camera time accurate to local time.

Moscow / Pullman / Lewiston, Idaho, United States (Other Investigation on 11/13/2022 at (Surveillance Review)) File # 9A-SU-3683464 Date drafted 02/06/2023 by HILLE ROB This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned to your agency; it and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.

013514

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22), On 11/13/2022, Page 2 of 15 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID 1330 PARKING Camera time accurate to local time.

451 Paradise Drive, Moscow, ID Camera time accurate to local time.

1455 SE Bishop Blvd, Pullman, WA, CH 10, Pullman, WA Camera time approximately seven seconds behind local time.

NE Stadium Way at SE Nevada, Pullman, WA [Washington State University (WSU)] Camera time accurate to local time.

NE Stadium Way at Grimes, Pullman, WA (WSU) Camera time accurate to local time.

NE Stadium Way at Wilson Rd, Pullman, (WSU) WA Camera time accurate to local time.

NE Stadium, Way at Cougar Way, Pullman, (WSU) WA Camera time accurate to local time.

301 5th Street, Clarkston, WA (Costco) Camera time accurate to local time.

820 Port Drive, Clarkston, WA (U.S. Chef Store) Camera time approximately one minute behind local time.

400 Bridge Street, Clarkston, WA (Albertson's) Camera time accurate to local time within one minute.

1300 Johnson Avenue, Pullman, WA (E & S Services) Camera time is approximately one minute and 30 seconds behind local time.

The following is intended as a summary of the collected surveillance footage and is not intended to be an all-encompassing report on the entirety of the collected video.

[Agent Note: For a visual representation of the sightings listed below, maps have been provided as reference documents. For the Indian Hills addresses below, please refer to " Map 1. " For the remainder of the addresses in Moscow, ID, please refer to " Map 2 " Digital copies of Map 1 and Map 2 will be attached to the 1A section of the case file.]

Time: Date: Location:
013515

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022 Page 3 of 15 Sightings in the Moscow, ID / Pullman, WA area:
03:26:10 a.m. November 13, 2022 787 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen driving westbound on Indian Hills Drive.

3:26:35 a.m. November 13, 2022 763 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho
Summary: The headlights of a vehicle are seen traveling westbound on Indian Hills Drive.

3:26:43 a.m. November 13, 2022 755 Indian Hills Drive, Moscow, Idaho
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling westbound on Indian Hills Drive.

3:28:56 a.m. November 13, 2022 1311 S Main Street, Moscow, ID, Channel 7
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling westbound on Styner Avenue crossing Main Street and continuing westbound onto Lauder Avenue.

3:29:02 a.m. November 13, 2022 1125 Ridge Road, Apt 108, Moscow, ID, Camera 2
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling westbound on Lauder Avenue through the intersection of Lauder Avenue / Ridge Road.

3:29:04 a.m. November 13, 2022 1125 Ridge Road, Apt 108, Moscow, ID, Camera 1 013516

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22), On 11/13/2022, Page 4 of 15
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 continues on Lauder Avenue as the road curves to the north toward Taylor Avenue.

3:29:48 a.m. November 13, 2022 1320 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID, 1320 Dumpster
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling westbound on Taylor Ave past Linda Lane.

3:30:22 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling southbound on King Road, turning east onto Queen Road.

3:30:55 a.m. November 13, 2022 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID
1330 PARKING

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels east along the north side of 500 Queen Road. The vehicle turns south along the east side of the building then turns west along the south side of the building.

The vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 exits the frame traveling west in the direction of 1122 King Road, Moscow, ID. (Hereafter referred to as " the victims ' residence. ")
3:31:18 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights briefly shine on upper exterior of 1127 King Road indicating a vehicle turning north toward Queen Road from the southern parking area of 500 Queen Road.

3:33:01 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels westbound on Queen Road turning north onto King Road. Headlights can be seen shining on trees to the west of the intersection of King Road and Taylor Avenue, indicating the vehicle turned west onto Taylor Avenue.

013517

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 5 of 15
3:33:36 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen southbound on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road Drive.

3:35:13 a.m. November 13, 2022 451 Paradise Drive, Moscow, ID, Shop
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels south on Ridge Road turning westbound onto Paradise Drive.

3:35:14 a.m. November 13, 2022 451 Paradise Drive, Moscow, ID, Front Door
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 continues westbound on Paradise Drive.

3:38:12 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen northbound on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road Drive.

3:38:34 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen southbound on King Road turning east on Queen Road
3:39:07 a.m. November 13, 2022 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID, 1330
PARKING

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels east on Queen Road along the north side of 500 Queen Road. The vehicle turns south along the east side of the building then turns west along the south side of the building. The vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 exits the frame traveling west in the direction of the victims ' residence.

013518

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 6 of 15
3:39:35 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights briefly shine on upper exterior of 1127 King Road indicating a vehicle turning north toward Queen Road from the southern parking area of 500 Queen Road.

3:40:24 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling west on Queen Road, turning north onto King Road. Headlights can be seen shining on trees to the west of the intersection of King Road and Taylor Avenue, indicating the vehicle turned west onto Taylor Avenue.

3:41:01 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:43:46 a.m. November 13, 2022 451 Paradise Drive, Moscow, ID, Shop
Summary: Vehicle headlights turn east onto Paradise Drive from Ridge Road. A reflection of the headlights indicates the vehicle may have made an immediate U-turn back onto Ridge Road, northbound.

3:45:07 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling north on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:47:08 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

013519

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022 Page 7 of 15
3:48:47 a.m. November 13, 2022 451 Paradise Drive, Moscow, ID, Shop
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 turns east onto Paradise Drive from Ridge Road. A reflection of headlights indicate the vehicle may have made an immediate U-turn back onto Ridge Road northbound.

3:50:27 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling north on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:51:26 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:52:42 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:53:36 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling north on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

3:56:24 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels south on King Road and turns east onto Queen Road.

3:56:57 a.m. November 13, 2022 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID, 013520

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 8 of 15
1330 PARKING

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels east along the north side of 500 Queen Road. The vehicle turns south along the east side of the building then turns west along the south side of the building.

The vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 exits the frame traveling west in the direction of the victims ' residence.

3:57:27 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights briefly shine on the upper exterior of 1127 King Road indicating a vehicle turning north toward Queen Road; the headlights disappear approximately 5 seconds later.

3:58:23 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow,
ID

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels west on Queen Road and turns north onto King Road. Headlights can be seen shining on trees to the west of the intersection of King Road and Taylor Avenue, indicating the vehicle turned west onto Taylor Avenue.

3:59:04 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

4:00:14 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling north on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

4:01:30 a.m. November 13, 2022 1125 Ridge Road, Apt 108, Moscow, ID Camera 1
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels south then east on Lauder Avenue.

013521

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 9 of 15
4:01:43 a.m. November 13, 2022 1125 Ridge Road, Apt 108, Moscow, ID Camera 2
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 turns from eastbound Lauder Avenue onto southbound Ridge Road.

4:04:20 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling north on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

4:04:56 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels south on King Road and turns east onto Queen Road.

4:05:31 a.m. November 13, 2022 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID,
1330 PARKING

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 pulls partially into east-side parking lot of the 500 Queen Road apartment buildings (from north side of the buildings, moving east). The vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 then completes a three-point turn, and returns westbound (along north side of apartment buildings).

4:06:09 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are visible in a window reflection, as well as on the exterior of 1119 King Road; indicating the vehicle is facing west on Queen Road. The lights appear to move slowly indicating the vehicle is descending the hill while passing by the front of the victim's residence
4:06:31 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels west on 013522

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 10 of 15 Queen Road, performs a U-Turn at the intersection with King Road then travels east on Queen Road.

4:07:28 a.m. November 13, 2022 1330 Linda Lane, Moscow, ID,
1330 PARKING

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels east along the north side of 500 Queen Road. The vehicle turns south along the east side of the building then turns west along the south side of the building.

The vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 exits the frame traveling west in the direction of the victims ' residence.

4:07:47 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights of a vehicle turning north onto Queen Road briefly shine on exterior of 1127 King Road. There is no subsequent vehicle activity captured for approximately 13 minutes after these headlights are seen.

4:20:47 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow,
ID

Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 travels westbound on Queen Road at a high rate of speed, turning north onto King Road.

Headlights can be seen shining on trees to the west of the intersection of King Road and Taylor Avenue, indicating the vehicle turned west onto Taylor Avenue.

4:21:05 a.m. November 13, 2022 1112 King Road, Moscow, ID
Summary: Headlights are seen traveling south on Walenta Drive behind 1119 King Road.

05:26:59 a.m. November 13, 2022 1300 Johnson Avenue, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling northbound on Johnson Avenue.

013523

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 11 of 15 [Agent Note: Due to the speed of the vehicle and its distance from the camera, the vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is difficult to identify. However, this vehicle is seen driving northbound on Bishop Boulevard, followed shortly after by a semi-truck. Moments later the white sedan is seen on the following cameras, still followed by the semi-truck.] [Agent Note: The camera at 1330 Johnson Avenue shows two separate roads, Johnson Avenue and Bishop Boulevard. Johnson Avenue is in the foreground and Bishop Boulevard is in the background. In this surveillance the vehicle matching Vehicle 1 is seen on Johnson Avenue while the semi-truck traveling behind the vehicle is on Bishop Boulevard.] [Agent Note: Actual time, with time stamp offset is approximately 05:25:29.]

05:25:30 a.m. November 13, 2022 1455 SE Bishop Boulevard, Pullman, WA, CH 10
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen turning from northbound Johnson Ave onto northbound Bishop Boulevard and continues northbound.

[Agent Note: This time is approximate, determined by time comparison with other cameras at the same business, due to frame glitches in the surveillance footage.]

5:26:22 a.m. November 13, 2022 1455 SE Bishop Boulevard, Pullman, WA, CH 14
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling northbound Bishop Boulevard toward E Main Street (Highway 270).

5:26:46 a.m. November 13, 2022 1455 SE Bishop Boulevard, Pullman, WA, CH 14
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 turns onto northbound E Main Street (Highway 270).

5:28:31 a.m. November 13, 2022 NE Stadium Way at SE Nevada 013524

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Surveillance Review (11/13/22) On 11/13/2022, Page 12 of 15 Street, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen turning onto NE Stadium Way from E Main Street (Highway 270). Vehicle 1 continues northeast through the intersection.

5:28:44 a.m. November 13, 2022 NE Stadium Way at SE Nevada Street, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 continues northeast on NE Stadium Way through the intersection.

5:29:33 a.m. November 13, 2022 NE Stadium Way at Grimes Way, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 continues north on NE Stadium Way through the intersection.

5:29:41 a.m. November 13, 2022 NE Stadium Way at Wilson Road, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 continues north on NE Stadium Way through the intersection.

5:30:18 a.m. November 13, 2022 NE Stadium Way at Cougar Way, Pullman, WA
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is northbound on NE Stadium Way then turns eastbound onto NE Orchard Drive.

9:12:59 a.m. November 13, 2022 1311 S Main Street, Moscow, ID, Channel 1
Summary: A vehicle matching the description of Vehicle 1 is seen traveling southbound on Highway 95.

013525

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
9A-SU-3683464

Continu