Court Filing
22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 11 LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 09/23/2024 to 09/23/2024 Packaging Information Agency Item # 24M-1284 Desc: Item 913 ██████ Fingerprin Lab Item # 137 Desc: two fingerprint cards bearing the name ███████████████████ (137.1, 137.2) Task / Test Value Date Opened 09/23/2024 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Agency Item # 24M-1332 Desc: Item 918 ██████ Fngrprnts Lab Item # 138 Desc: three fingerprint cards bearing the name ███████████████████ (138.1-138.3) Task / Test Value Date Opened 09/23/2024 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Latent Analysis Task / Test Value Latent # or Lift # L5 Date 09/23/2024 Orientation Known? Yes Anatomic Source Finger NV Impressions Present Pattern Source ███████████████████████████████████ Clarity 1, 2, and 3 Complexity non-complex Pressure Medium Distortion areas of higher pressure or excess amido. smears. some surface lines. Dev. Medium amido black Substrate plastic-slider door in kitchen of house-facing kitchen (interior) Preservation Digital image Comparison Value Yes MBIS Quality Previously searched Examiner Notes crime scene images 5840 and 5841 copied from original analysis dated 11/20/22 Verified Yes Verifier: Logan Pacheco Verified Date 09/23/2024 Verifier Notes Copied from original analysis dated 4/24/2024; ███████████████████████████████ matrix / smearing, voids, surface, higher pressure in some areas?; Latent L5 EXC from FPC BTN █████████████████████████; LJP Digital images stored in Digital images stored in Foray / Adams Web Foray / Adams Web Task / Test Value Latent # or Lift # L6 Date 09/23/2024 Orientation Known? Yes Anatomic Source Finger NV Impressions Present Pattern Source ███████ plus some joint Clarity 1 and 2 Complexity low complexity Page 1 of 3 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 11 LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 09/23/2024 to 09/23/2024 Pressure Medium Distortion voids. matrix? possible movement Dev. Medium amido black Substrate plastic-slider door in kitchen of house-facing patio (outside) Preservation Digital image Comparison Value Yes MBIS Quality No Examiner Notes copied from original analysis dated 11/20/22 some similarity to # 10 ██████ cannot exclude but cannot ID; INCL. TMM 09/23/24 Verified Yes Verifier: Logan Pacheco Verified Date 09/23/2024 Verifier Notes Copied from original analysis dated 4/24/2024; ████████ with possible some joint; voids, matrix / development medium? very low Q / Q but pattern type and partial delta visible; very borderline for comparison value.; Some similarity to # 10 ███████ but dissimilarities also present. Due to the low quality of the latent, unable to EXC; INCL to FPC BTN █████████████████████████; LJP Exemplars Task / Test Value Exemplar Name ████████████████████ Name on Card (if different) █████████████████████████ Exemplar Identifier Items 137.1-137.2 Type of Card Finger Quality of Exemplar Medium Obtained From Agency Exemplar Notes no recorded by, agency or date listed 137.2 is the same as 137.1 but 137.1 is a green FPC and 137.2 is a white card, only scanned in 137.1 in Foray, 137.2 scanned for documentation Task / Test Value Exemplar Name ████████████████████ Name on Card (if different) █████████████████████████ Exemplar Identifier Items 138.1-138.3 Type of Card Finger Quality of Exemplar Medium Obtained From Agency Exemplar Notes no recorded by, agency or date listed 138.2 and 138.3 are the same as 138.1 but 138.1 and 138.2 are green FPC and 138.3 is a white card, only scanned in 138.1 in Foray, others scanned for documentation exemplars are all the same but 138 has been printed by agency at 1200 dpi, per my conversation with them and the note they left on the exemplar. Page 2 of 3 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 11 LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 09/23/2024 to 09/23/2024 Comparison Table L5 EXC ███████████████ L6 INCL Page 3 of 3 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 11 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 5 of 11 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE WASHINGTON, D.C., 20537 PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION To obtain classifiable fingerprints: 1. Use printer's ink. 2. Distribute ink evenly on inking slab. 3. Wash and dry fingers thoroughly. 4. Roll fingers from nail to nail, and avoid allowing fingers to slip. 5. Be sure impressions are recorded in correct order. 6. If an amputation or deformity makes it impossible to print a finger, make a notation to that effect in the individual finger block. 7. If some physical condition makes it impossible to obtain perfect impressions, submit the best that can be obtained with a memo stapled to the card explaining the circumstances. 8. Examine the completed prints to see if they can be classified, bearing in mind the following: Most fingerprints fall into the patterns shown below. Other patterns occur infrequently and are not shown here. WHORL ARCH DELTAS PASTE PHOTO HERE (OPTIONAL) THESE LINES RUNNING BETWEEN ARCHES HAVE NO DELTAS DELTAS MUST BE CLEAR LOOP CENTER OF LOOP DELTA THE LINES BETWEEN CENTER OF LOOP AND DELTA MUST SHOW FD-353 (REV. 3-21-83) U.S. G.P.O. 1998: 432-177 / 60041 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 6 of 11 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 7 of 11 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 8 of 11 T FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE WASHINGTON, D.C., 20537 PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION To obtain classifiable fingerprints: 1. Use printer's ink. 2. Distribute ink evenly on inking slab. 3. Wash and dry fingers thoroughly. 4. Roll fingers from nail to nail, and avoid allowing fingers to slip. 5. Be sure impressions are recorded in correct order. 6. If an amputation or deformity makes it impossible to print a finger, make a notation to that effect in the individual finger block. 7. If some physical condition makes it impossible to obtain perfect impressions, submit the best that can be obtained with a memo stapled to the card explaining the circumstances. 8. Examine the completed prints to see if they can be classified, bearing in mind the following: Most fingerprints fall into the patterns shown below. Other patterns occur infrequently and are not shown here. WHORL ARCH 141 DELTAS PASTE PHOTO HERE (OPTIONAL) THESE DELTAS LINES MUST RUNNING BE CLEAR BETWEEN ARCHES HAVE NO DELTAS LOOP CENTER OF LOOP DELTA THE LOOP LINES AND BETWEEN DELTA MUST CENTER SHOW OF FD-353 (REV. 3-21-83) U.S. G.P.O. 1998: 432-177 / 60041 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 9 of 11 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 10 of 11 T FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE WASHINGTON, D.C., 20537 PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION To obtain classifiable fingerprints: 1. Use printer's ink. 2. Distribute ink evenly on inking slab. 3. Wash and dry fingers thoroughly. 4. Roll fingers from nail to nail, and avoid allowing fingers to slip. 5. Be sure impressions are recorded in correct order. 6. If an amputation or deformity makes it impossible to print a finger, make a notation to that effect in the individual finger block. 7. If some physical condition makes it impossible to obtain perfect impressions, submit the best that can be obtained with a memo stapled to the card explaining the circumstances. 8. Examine the completed prints to see if they can be classified, bearing in mind the following: Most fingerprints fall into the patterns shown below. Other patterns occur infrequently and are not shown here. WHORL ARCH DELTAS PASTE PHOTO HERE (OPTIONAL) THESE LINES RUNNING BETWEEN ARCHES HAVE NO DELTAS DELTAS MUST BE CLEAR LOOP OF CENTER LOOP DELTA THE LOOP LINES AND BETWEEN DELTA MUST CENTER SHOW OF FD-353 (REV. 3-21-83) U.S. G.P.O. 1998: 432-177 / 60041 22-M09903 # 41 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 11 of 11