Court Filing
22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 29 FIELD SERVICES ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of Analysis: 12/29/22-3/21/2023 Scene Personnel Task Value Scene Response Date 12/29/2022 Person Tara Martinez Total travel time 10.50 Total time on Scene (s) 16.65 # of Locations 2 Scene Response Date 12/29/2022 Person Hailey Youngling Total travel time 10.50 Total time on Scene (s) 16.65 # of Locations 2 Scene Response Date 12/29/2022 Person Jennie Ayers Total travel time 10.50 Total time on Scene (s) 16.65 # of Locations 2 General Crime Scene Task Value Response Event / Location ███████████████████████ Pullman, WA Photography Yes Image # 5891 to Image # 6141 Total # of Images 251 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram No # of Presumptive Blood Tests 51 # of Biological Stains / Items 3 Collected Other test (s) performed No Other item (s) collected yes # of Other item (s) collected 12 Type (s) of Other Evidence nitrile glove, receipts (3), vacuum dust canister, possible hair strands (13), FireTV stick, computer tower Response Event / Location ███████████████████████ Pullman, WA Photography Yes Image # 8118 to Image # 8528 Total # of Images 411 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram No Other test (s) performed No Response Event / Location ████████████████████████████████████████ Pullman, WA Photography Yes Image # 8529 to Image # 8583 Total # of Images 55 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram No Other test (s) performed No General Notes Task Value C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ FS_MATRIX.rpt Page 1 of 2 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 29 FIELD SERVICES ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of Analysis: - 3/21/2023 General Notes Entry # 2 added to add additional photos taken with another camera. All testing info is in Entry # 1-only photos are in Entry # 2. Verification of Accompanying Personnel Task Value Information Verified yes Verified By: Hailey Youngling Date Reviewed by Accompanying 02/17/2023 Responder Notes from Accompanying 01/24/2023 HMY: for the # of presumptive tests, I think the number should be 51, since marker A Responder wasn't tested just collected- update 52 to 51 in the report, " FS Ayers performed a presumptive test for the presence of blood on 52 areas inside the apartment " In the report: " East of the closet are two bedrooms, one on the west side, one on the east side " Maybe add something about the bedrooms also being north, maybe " East of the closet, on the north side of the apartment, are two bedrooms, one on the west side, one on the east side "? Information Verified yes Verified By: Jennifer (Jennie) Ayers Date Reviewed by Accompanying 02/27/2023 Responder Notes from Accompanying 02/15/23 JA Responder In both locations, change FS to Forensic Scientists (plural) " AC " unit- spell out to air conditioning double check that items in apartment are past tense For presumptive blood, changed to " performed presumptive tests " (plural) In opening paragraph for office, change " arrived to the residence " to " arrived to the office " or something similar █████████ well kept " change to " was "; " living room is furnished " change to " was "; " northwest bedroom is unfurnished " change to " was "; LizQ Imaging Task Value LizQ Imaging Location ██████████████████████████ # of Captures 14 # of sphericals 14 LizQ Total Images Captured 1386 General Notes Outdoor captures (221 and 234) did not have low / high. Indoor captures all included low / high. C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ FS_MATRIX.rpt Page 2 of 2 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 29 ISPFS CRIME SCENE RESPONSE Call out received date: 12/28/22 time: 1102 by: Jennie Ayers Locati ████████████████████████████ Pullman WA Agency: SP D2 INV Agency Case #: Search Warrant obtained? N Incident Date: 11/13/22 Details: Search warrants to be executed at suspect's apartment. and office. Looking for blood, trace, knife, anything else to tic suspect to scene and / or victims. will coordinate with WA agency. * any additional requests for processing shall be documented in the case notes * * Date: 12/30/2022 ISPFS Personnel: Jennie Ayers Enroute: 0529 PST Tara Martinez Arrived: 0711 PST Hailey Youngling Clear: 2055 PST Crime Type: Back to ISPFS: ISPFS Lab #: M2022 4843 m 2022 4870 Scene Security: [] entry log [] barrier tape () Officer (s) posted Weather: Spow / Rain / Windy / Clear / Cloudy / Cold / Hot Temperature: 33 ° F Briefed by: Walk through: (time) Officers / Detectives Present: Victim / Suspect / Subject: Bryan Ronberger DOB: ██████████████ Victim / Suspect / Subject: DOB: Victim / Suspect / Subject: DOB: Victim / Suspect / Subject: DOB: Vehicle (s): Coroner: Arrival: Mortuary: Arrival: Body bag seal #: Photography Presumptive Blood test (s) Trace Evidence [] Video [] Blood enhancement [] Footwear / Tire Tracks [] Sketch [] Bloodstain Pattern Analysis () Latent Print Processing [] Location / Dimensions [] Shooting Reconstruction [] Major Case Prints [] ALS exam (note unit & nm) () Firearms Evidence LizQ []] 5841- 6141 Digital images numbered $ 118 to $ 583 A Digital images uploaded to Foray TM 이 Digital images provided to agency via: ✗ digital transfer. _thumb drive / CD / DVD T. martinez transferred images [y] Results of processing / chemical tests conveyed to Talbott to tallbutt on 12/31/2122 @approx. 0910 PST Page of 2 Initials M 19 TOTAL PAGES: I OF 15 TM31723 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 29 ISPFS CRIME SCENE RESPONSE BRIEFING NOTES ISPFS Lab #: M7022 4843 Briefed by: Blaker (moscow PD), Talbrott (ISP D2) Suspect to be arrested @ W0200 EST. Investigative information: Soft entry into suspect's apartment-photo & LizQ, then prosecutor will do walk through. Apartment IS on █████ Floor, consists of 2 bedrooms, I bath, Kitchen, living room, s balcony per schematic. Types of evidence included in search warrant / consent: [DNA (blood, saliva, semen, hair, other bodily fluids) or items that may bear DNA [] Latent prints (fingerprints, palm prints, sole prints) or items that may bear impressions [] MCP's Electronics [] Tire Impressions [] Firearms / Firearms related ✓ Clothing [] Footwear Impressions [] Blunt weapons [] Indicia of ownership [Trace (hair, fiber, shavings, etc.) Sharp edged weapons [] Drugs / Paraphernalia [] Additional requests requests / information from investigating agency: Electronics, handwritten journals wsu office-computer swabs of mouse & phone. wilson Short Hall " 1475 Glen Gary Terrell mau fullman WA 12/21/22 Wsl Police to assist as apartment and office are both on wsu property. Page 2 of 2 Initials m Him TOTAL: 2 OF 18031723 19 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 5 of 29 LizQ Capture Notes Date: 12/30/22 Lab Number: M2022-4843 Location: ███████████████████████ ███████████████████████ Analyst (s): Jennie Ayers CAPTURE # ROOM or GENERAL LOCATION OF LIZO DIMENSIONS FOR ITEM IN LOCATION FOR LOW (HIGH AREA (Room / Location) 22 PHOTOGRAMMETRY (LxWxH) cm 121312) N of Sidewaek N & slightly 1.32 inches Item: radiator building w of staircase Hadirs W: 6.5 inches north harth 221 on G to 6201 H: ile inches Wall livias S. of coffee tabie L: 62 inches Item: radiator w: 16 inches on South 222223 room H: 20.75 inches wall living livingroom @ 45 Kitchen Center of kitchen L: 62 inches Item: radiator 224 225 W: 6 inches on south H: 20.75 inches wall (living ro 245 NE / approx Center of L: 72 inch Item: Desk Bedroom. W: 23.25 inches 226 22245 room H: 36 inches top NW / aprox Center of L: 32 inches Item: radittor 228 229 Bedroom. W: 6.5inches on north roum wall e45 H: 16 inches Bathroom Just east of the 1: 26 inches Item: radiator 230 229/231 toilet room wall w: 4 inches on East 2245 H: 14 inches wall Nend E.Side of hallway L: 62 inches Item: radiator 233 of living W: Ce inches on south wall 232 room H: 20.75 inches radiator 245 balcony west of door L: Item: near railing W: 234 H: L: Item: W: H: L: Item: W: H: L: Item: W: H: Images turned over to Talbott at 1148 PST 12/31/2022 by J. Ayers Page of Initials 19 1783 Huy TOTAL: 3 OF 18 TM 03 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 6 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/22 Time: 1543 PST Lab Number: M2022-4843 Chemical Lot #: 1200-33620 Analyst (s): J.Ayers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS (Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECT COLLECTED COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY white towel from Shelf Of Kitchen Table. Diluted X red brown irregular stain dark red Spot, small-flaked Unable Ayers Collected Totest A off surface upon touch. west of X Sink, Kitchen w / o-fest Counter Pizza cutter, top drawer west of sink, East of fridge. X reddish Scratch in Metal Dark Side red irregular in 031723 panel of drawer-second X KITCHEN west of sink 3132 screw driver from τη bottom drawer, west of sink X PROM brown spot Ajax bottle of soap, near bottom ALL edge on west Side of Sink X Small dark stain Ajax bottle of Soap, near bottom, linear stain X switch on north wall of Kitchen behind Sink. dark X reddish Stain Switch on north wall of kitchen behind sink, small X dark reddish Stain Pink / red imegular Stain on edge of Plate. From dra X cabinet west of sink Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N 19 Page of M TOTAL 4 OF 18 M131723 Amy : 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 7 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/2022 Time: Lab Number: M2022-4843 Chemical Lot #: 1200-33620 Analyst (s): J. Ayers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECT COLLECTED COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY Microwave on Counter in Kitchen, NE corner. dark LENTELOR) reddish long Stain in back dark discoloration in of counter tile just south of X microwave orange drip. South wall of Kitchen. East of window X NE bedroom. NECloset. interior of north door. Dark red stains- X Multiple, Irregular and pieces Small red brown stain on Exterior door of NE Closet X In NE bedroom, (north door) Edge of South door of NE Closet In NE bedroom. vem Small X ned brown stain Interior of South closet door North door. faint stains Swipe X marks. Neroom Two small reddish brownirregular Stain. inside of South Closet X north EAST ROOM TM 010323 Irregular reddish brown stain. Inside south closet of Nt room X north side of vertical wall in center Winite towel on black i brown Stool. Dark brown stain in X towel fibers. NE ROUM The 017373 Evidence turned over to at (tiates (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N Page 2 of 19 TM tuy TOTAL: 5 OF 18 M 031723 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 8 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/2022 Time: Lab Number: M2022-4843 Chemical Lot #: 1200-33620 Analyst (s): J. Ayers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS: Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECTED COLLECT COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY gray smear. interior of South door of South closet X of NE bedroom thebettoen of laundry basket underside orange orange smear. X Ne room light brown streak outside Corner of laundry basket X NE bedroom Exterior door of NE bedroom Small red stain, round X Irregular red stain Exterior door of NE bedroom X NE bedroom door Jambwest West Side side of of door Jamb. X small brown stain small red / brown stain, exterior of bathroom door X Interior of bathroom door, Small dark / red / brown X Irregular stain interior of bathroom door!?) little red / brown Stain Hy X 1/23/23 light reddish brown Stain on outside edge of medicine X Cabinet BATHROOM THE 63 1723 Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N Page 3 of 6 19 THMY TOTAL: 6 OF HE TM 0.3 1773 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 9 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/2022 Time: Lab Number: M2022-4843 Chemical Lot #: 1200-331020 Analyst (s): J. Ayers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS: Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECT COLLECTED COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY dilute brown stain on East Side of door Jamb of toilet X room in bathroom Small reddish brown stain on left edge of medicine X cabinet mirror, bathroom small brownish stain right Inside edge of medicine X cabinet, bathroom brownish Stain Just above tile below towel rack below X medicine cabinet, bathroom west wall of Shower sn sho below curtain rod. light X gray linear stain East sink of Vanity wood front face below counter top X light red stain irregular, bathroom reddish brown stain, irregular Shape left wall of cabinet X Under East sink, bathroom reddish brown linear Stain On Un right side of shelf of X Cabinet under East sink, bathroom light orange / brown stain, linear irregular. Right side of sink, X Bathroom 031723 -EAST SINK TM twn East Wall of shower collected allboy hair, See Collection log marker 8 Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N Page 4 of 6 19 TM 18 1780 tum TOTAL: 7 OF 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 10 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/2022 Time: Lab Number: M2022-4843 Chemical Lot #: 1200-33620 Analyst (s): J.Ayers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS: Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECT COLLECTED COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY Curtain rod in Shower, under Side of rod west end X reddish stain blind Swab of East Sink drain, bathroom X blind Swab of west Sink drain, bathroom X blind Swab of Shower drain, bathroom X tiny red stain on edge of door knob plate interior X of entry door. 1723 South of enth door in X living room west wall, dark brown dripping stain 03 TM top, left side of computer pad. Dilute, round stain X BEDROOM top left side of Computer X pad. Dilute, round stain NE reddish brown stain on J.Ayer's FROM B un cased pillow, South Side X X of bed. Two separate Stains, only Cut larger tested Sthin Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N Page 5 of 6 19 TOTAL: 8 OF 1 tm BAB 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 11 of 29 Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood Date: 12/30/2022 Lab Number: M2022-4843 Time: Chemical Lot #: 1200-33620 Analyst (s): J. Avers Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS: Pink (circle results) RESULTS COLLECTION INCONCLUSIVE NO COLLECTED COLLECT COLLECTION MARKER # POSITIVE NEGATIVE CUTTING OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY matress cover on bed in Tmartinez C NE room on edge facing X X doorway. Brown irregular drip. multiple Stains present on cover Collected after one positive result, other stains not tested. cover un zips into 2 pieces. top piece and bottom piece collected / packaged Separately-bath marked Item C underside of rug under Coffee Hable in living room. Brownish X Staining, near tag. Nuwcorner of rug. linear brownish red stain on X Carpet in living room, unders Interior north side X red irregular stain Evidence turned over to at (date) (lime) Evidence S & S-Y / N 19 Page 6 of b TOTAL: 9 OF 18723 im Hun 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 12 of 29 Evidence Collection Log Date: 12/30/2022 Lab Number: M2022-4843 Location: ██████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████ Analyst (s): H.Youngling ████████ Pullman WA COLLECTION PHOTO NO COLLECTED COLLECT COLLECTION MARKER # CUTTING OR IN SWAB SITU ITEM IDENTIFIER DESCRIPTION OF ITEM OF EVIDENCE LOCATION BY ome nitrile type black Closet on N wall MartinR I glove of entry way (weside) X T. one " Walmart " receipt with Closet on N Wall 2 one " dickies " tag of entry way lwest X Side) two " marshalls " receipts Closet on N wall of 3 entry way (west side) Dust Container from Closet N Wall of 4 Bissell Power-force " Vaccum entry way (East side) X toro possible hair strands head of " Libman " 5 broom, Closet N Wall of light entry way LEastside) AAA " Fire TV " Stick plugged into back 1212. X 6 with cord of " Samsung " TV / plug West wall, living room TV Stand possible animal hair strand NE bedroom, inder computer 7 Under computer pad on desk in pad on desk. X NE bedroom possible hair East wall East wall of shower 8 of shower, on file, on tile, bathroom X possible hair inside drain inside drain of Shomer 9 of Shower, bathroom bathroom X possible hair under Computer pad on 10 computer pad on desk in desk in NE bedram X V NE bedroona Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N 19 TM Page of 2 TOTAL 10 OF to 1773 Hm : me 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 13 of 29 Evidence Collection Log Date: 12/30/2022 Lab Number: m2022-4843 Location: █████████████████████████████████ █████████████████████████████████ Analyst (s): COLLECTION PHOTO COLLECT NO COLLECTED COLLECTION MARKER # CUTTING OR IN SWAB SITU ITEM IDENTIFIER DESCRIPTION OF ITEM OF EVIDENCE LOCATION BY one possible hair strand NE bedroom marting = 11 from un cased pillow, east X Side of bed. north 1. Computer tower from NE bedroom Ayers 12 NE bedroom desk #Item not bagged, tagge X 1. w / ziptie and info Evidence turned over to at (date) (time) Evidence S & S-Y / N 19 TM Page 2 of 2 TOTAL: 11 OF ST る HM 22-M09903 # 25 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 14 of 29 12/30/2022 ██████████████████████████████ ██████████████████████████████ Pullman WA Weather: ~ 33 ° F, Snowy, wet, drippy arrived @residence approx. 0705 PST exterior of building is beige, marked with maroon / brown letter █████ Six-plex apartment building, apartments 3011 302 adjoined with another six-plex 2033 20 1011021 knocked & announced @ 0712 PST Talbot (ISPD2) and Dustin Blaker (MoscowPD) entered @ 0717 PST as well as Deputy Cheif Daniels Cush PD) apartment ████ is on the ███████ floor on the █████ side of building. █████ floors has a half flight staircase going down to " ground level " which is slightly below ground. ███████ floor staircase is flush with surrounding side. walk and a has a single flight of stairs going up. entry to apartment ████ is directly east of staircase. apartment █████ is directly across from ███ with on the West █████████████████ Side of building with a ████████████████████████████████████████ singe staifase flights going ███████████ Further west of ████████████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████████████ ████████████████████████████████████████ building (townhome) ██ is a large, multiple unit mail boxstrictive and bevond are HMY 3/17/20 buildings ████████████████████████████████████████ ████████████ ████████████████████████████████████████ " East of to play ground area ████████████████████████████████████████ is a small concrete basketball Court. 12120122 Building " L " is directly east of bavilding k, which is east of building J On the backside of building nilding ███ each apartment has a balcony. ██