Court Filing
The 20 most-mentioned. The full list is in the case file.
IDAHO POLICE - STATE - IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES 700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202 Phone: (208) 884-7170 Fax: (208) 884-7197 FORENSIC FIELD SERVICES REPORT Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s): Laboratory Case No.: MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843 Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.: 11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 11 Analyst: Tara Martinez Case Name (s): Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES Field Notes: On 11/16/22 at approximately 1912 PST, Forensic Scientists (FS) Kerry Hogan, Hailey Youngling, Jennie Ayers, Wyatt Barie and I arrived at the Idaho State Police District 2 (ISP D2) office located at 2700 Old N S Hwy, Lewiston, Idaho 83501, to assist with a homicide investigation. Detective Talbott (ISP D2) was present upon our arrival. Detective Talbott briefed us on the scene information. 1122 King Rd. On 11/17/22 at approximately 0854 PST, FS Hogan, Youngling, Ayers, Barie and I arrived at 1122 King Rd, Moscow, Idaho 83843. Detective Talbott was present upon our arrival. 1122 King Rd is a white colored three story home that faces north in a residential neighborhood. The house consists of 6 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. The first floor consists of a west bedroom, a bathroom, a furnace room, an east bedroom and a stairway to the second floor. The second floor consists of a living room, a bathroom, a west bedroom, an east bedroom, a kitchen, a storage room under the stairs and a switchback staircase to the third floor. The third floor consists of a west bedroom, a landing, a bathroom and an east bedroom. The second floor west bedroom had few belongings. A bed was against the south wall and a table with two drawers was against the north wall. A freestanding mirror and furry chair were in the northwest corner of the room. There were a number of apparent bloodstains on the bed, the south wall, the west wall, the door and the floor. In the third floor east bedroom a bed was against the north wall and a closet was against the south wall. A desk was against the west wall. There were a number of apparent bloodstains on the bed, the north wall, the east wall, the west wall and the door. FS Barie and Ayers took photographs of the scene using the LizQ Imaging System. Page 1 of 5 STATE'S EXHIBIT exhibitsticker.com S-15 (b) 014921 Case No. CR01-24-31665 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 11 I photographed the scene for overall location, identification and condition. FS Hogan and Detective Talbott placed markers for all of the stains that were previously labeled and collected by ISP detectives (ISP D2 markers 23-46, 48, 49, 59, and 60). An additional 21 stains were marked by ISPFS (letters B, D-F, H-X) and collected by FS Barie. FS Hogan performed presumptive tests for the presence of blood on 61 areas from the scene, using Ortho-Tolidine. Stairway area between the first and second floors north wall of stairway (ISP D2 markers 23, 24 and ISPFS markers A, B, C) half wall of stairway (ISP D2 markers 25, 26, ISPFS markers D, E, V, W) west upper wall of stairway (ISP D2 marker 27) Second floor, leading to or part of the west bedroom north wall of hallway leading to west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 28) south wall of hallway leading to west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 38, ISPFS markers G, H, and an unmarked area) - edge of west bedroom door (ISP D2 marker 36 and ISPFS marker I) exterior of west bedroom door (ISPFS marker Q) - jamb of west bedroom door (ISPFS marker S) by / on light switch of west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 29) south wall of west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 30) west wall of west bedroom (ISP D2 markers 31 and 34) small table with one drawer in west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 32) floor of west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 33, 37, ISPFS marker R) garbage can in west bedroom (ISPFS marker T) furry chair in west bedroom (ISPFS marker U) table with two drawers in west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 35) Second floor, bathroom - edge of bathroom door white towel in bathroom Second floor, living room - folding table in living room (ISP D2 marker 39 and ISPFS marker F) right of bar cart in living room (ISP D2 marker 59) - - leg of bar cart white flower vase on bar cart Second floor, kitchen floor under north wall of kitchen cabinets (ISP D2 marker 40) north kitchen wall behind sink kitchen cabinet kitchen sink sliding glass door Area of switchback stairs between the second and third floors east wall, lower staircase (ISPFS marker J) west side of the half wall (ISPFS markers L and M) south side of the half wall (ISPFS marker K) the east side of the half wall (ISPFS markers N and O) Page 2 of 5 014922 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 11 - half wall banister (ISP D2 marker 41) Third floor bathroom door (ISP D2 marker 49) the ceiling outside of the east bedroom (ISPFS marker P) exterior of east bedroom door (ISP D2 marker 42) the interior edge of the east bedroom door (ISP D2 marker 48 and ISPFS marker X) the north wall of the east bedroom (ISP D2 marker 43) the east wall of the east bedroom (ISP D2 markers 44 and 45) the west wall of the closet of the east bedroom (ISP D2 marker 46) west wall of west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 60) The following stains were Ortho-Tolidine negative: Second floor south wall of hallway leading to west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 38) south wall of hallway leading to west bedroom (unmarked area) edge of bathroom door white towel in bathroom leg of bar cart white flower vase on bar cart floor under north wall of kitchen cabinets (ISP D2 marker 40) kitchen sink under north wall of upper kitchen cabinets kitchen cabinet sliding glass door Third floor west wall of west bedroom (ISP D2 marker 60) All other stains were Ortho-Tolidine positive, indicating the presence of blood. The following items were collected from the scene by FS Barie and I: one potential hair from the half wall between floors one and two (marker 5), two potential hairs from the second floor hallway leading to the west bedroom (markers 1 and 2), potential hairs from the second floor west bedroom door (marker 6), one cigarette butt from the exterior of the south side of the residence (marker 3), potential face, hand and finger marks from the exterior south kitchen window (markers 7-9), and one paper note located in the parking area (marker 4). FS Youngling powder processed the following areas: the exterior lower pane of the south kitchen window, the exterior frame around the lower pane of the south kitchen window, the area around the handle of the exterior and interior of the kitchen sliding glass door, and the frame and jamb of the interior of the kitchen sliding glass door. Six latent lift cards (latents L1 and L2) were collected from the exterior lower pane of the south kitchen window. I photographed the approximate size and location of bloodstains and / or groups of bloodstains in the second floor west bedroom and the third floor east bedroom. In the second floor west bedroom, bloodstains AA-AG were documented. In the third floor east bedroom, bloodstains BA-BL were documented. Page 3 of 5 014923 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 11 FS Youngling and I processed the following areas with Amido Black: upper handrail between the first and second floor, hallway leading to second floor west bedroom, second floor west bedroom floor, second floor west bedroom door knobs (interior and exterior), threshold of the second floor east bedroom, interior and exterior handle areas of the interior kitchen sliding glass door, door jamb of kitchen sliding glass door, interior threshold of the kitchen sliding glass door, edge of kitchen countertops, half wall railing between the second and third floor, and third floor east bedroom threshold and door knobs (interior and exterior). Latents L3-L6 were collected via photography, from the following: the second floor west bedroom floor (L3), the second floor east bedroom threshold (L4), the edge of the handle from the interior kitchen sliding glass door (L5), and above the handle of the exterior kitchen sliding glass door (L6). We cleared the scene on 11/18/22 at approximately 2114 PST. All evidence collected was turned over to Detective Talbott on 11/18/22 at approximately 2241 PST. We transferred digital images (including LizQ Imaging System captures) to Detective Talbott on 11/19/22 at approximately 0838 PST. On 11/19/22, at approximately 1113 PST, FS Hogan and I returned to 1122 King Rd. Moscow, Idaho 83843 to photograph potential tire impressions in the road across from the residence, as requested by Detective Talbott. I took photographs for overall location, condition and identification. I took comparison quality photographs of the potential tire impressions. We cleared the scene at approximately 1214 PST. I transferred digital images to Detective Talbott at approximately 1245 PST. 2011 Toyota Prius On 11/18/22 at approximately 1934 PST, FS Hogan and Barie arrived at 709 W Palouse Dr. Moscow, Idaho 83843 to process a vehicle. They were accompanied by Detective Tolleson (ISP D1). Detective Lehman (ISP D1) and the owner of the vehicle were also present upon their arrival. The vehicle is a 2011 grey colored Toyota Prius, license plate Idaho 1LG1226, VIN: JTDKN3DU7B5324142. The vehicle was located in a large vehicle bay. FS Hogan photographed the vehicle for overall location, identification and condition. FS Hogan and Barie searched the vehicle, but there were no significant findings. They cleared the scene at approximately 2044 PST. We transferred digital images to Detective Talbott on 11/19/22 at approximately 0838 PST. Page 4 of 5 014924 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 11 1127 King Rd. On 11/18/22 at approximately 2117 PST, FS Hogan arrived at 1127 King Rd. Moscow, Idaho 83843, to assist in the search of an apartment. FS Hogan was accompanied by Detective Talbott and Sergeant Van Leuven (ISP D1). 1127 King Rd is an apartment building consisting of two stories. Apartment “ 1 ” is located on the ground level and is a multi-bedroom apartment with two bathrooms, a living room and a kitchen. There is a hallway with a kitchen to the north and a living room area to the north of the kitchen. There is at least two bedrooms east of the kitchen. There are two bathrooms south of the kitchen, on the east side of the apartment. The response was limited to the southeast bedroom. FS Hogan performed two presumptive tests for the presence of blood on the south wall of the entry hallway (marker 1) and on the east wall of the kitchen (marker 2) using Ortho-Tolidine. Positive results, indicating the presence of blood, were obtained on both stains. Swabs were collected from markers 1 and 2 by FS Hogan. FS Hogan cleared at approximately 2224 PST. All collected swabs were turned over to Detective Talbott on 11/18/22 at approximately 2241 PST. We transferred digital images to Detective Talbott on 11/19/22 at approximately 0838 PST. DISPOSITION: Digital images are being retained by ISP Forensic Services. FS Youngling and I uploaded all digital images, excluding those from the LizQ Imaging System, to the digital imaging system on 11/19/22. REMARKS: I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct. Jau my Tara Martinez / Forensic Scientist Issue Date: 08/18/2023 Page 5 of 5 014925 22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 32 FIELD SERVICES ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of Analysis: 11/16/22-8/14/2023 Scene Personnel Task Value Scene Response Date 11/16/2022 Person Tara Martinez Total travel time 14.40 Total time on Scene (s) 26.10 # of Locations 1 Scene Response Date 11/16/2022 Person Kerry Hogan Total travel time 14.40 Total time on Scene (s) 26.10 # of Locations 3 Scene Response Date 11/16/2022 Person Wyatt Barie Total travel time 13.90 Total time on Scene (s) 25.00 # of Locations 2 Scene Response Date 11/16/2022 Person Jennie Ayers Total travel time 13.90 Total time on Scene (s) 25.00 # of Locations 1 Scene Response Date 11/16/2022 Person Hailey Youngling Total travel time 13.90 Total time on Scene (s) 25.00 # of Locations 1 General Crime Scene Task Value Response Event / Location 1122 King Rd. Moscow, Idaho Photography Yes Image # 0 to Image # 0 Total # of Images 2718 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram Yes # of Vehicle (s) Processed 0 # of Presumptive Blood Tests 62 # of Presumptive Semen Tests 0 # of Biological Stains / Items 21 Collected # of Latent Prints 4 # of LLC's 6 # of Prints Cast 0 # of Prints Photographed 4 Type of Latent Print Processing Powder Type of Latent Print Processing Amido Black # of Footwear Impressions 2 Photographed # of Footwear Impressions Cast 0 # of Tire Impressions 1 Photographed # of Tire Impressions Cast 0 Other test (s) performed No Other item (s) collected yes C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ FS_MATRIX.rpt Page 1 of 3 014926 22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 32 FIELD SERVICES ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of Analysis: - 8/14/2023 # of Other item (s) collected 10 Type (s) of Other Evidence hair, cigarette butt, paper note, possible face / hand / finger marks, router & modem Response Event / Location Prius-GPS Coordinates 46degrees 42'533 " N and 117degrees 00'32.6 " 709 W West Palouse Dr., Moscow, ID Photography Yes Image # 7915 to Image # 7973 Total # of Images 59 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram No # of Vehicle (s) Processed 1 # of Presumptive Blood Tests 0 Other test (s) performed No Response Event / Location 1127 King Rd., Apartment " 1 ", Moscow, Idaho Photography Yes Image # 7974 to Image # 8000 Total # of Images 27 ALS Exam No Sketch / Diagram No # of Presumptive Blood Tests 2 # of Biological Stains / Items 2 Collected Other test (s) performed No General Notes Task Value General Notes For entry # 1: the image numbers are 3374-5890 and 7915-8117; two separate cameras used. Total images: 2718 Verification of Accompanying Personnel Task Value Information Verified yes Verified By: Hailey Youngling Date Reviewed by Accompanying 02/28/2023 Responder Notes from Accompanying HMY 01/03/2023: Responder In the scene personnel, should your scene time be more than 25 to account for the tiremark work? Your scene time is the same as me, JA and BW but you went back to do the tire stuff. In the general crime scene, fill in the image numbers for the first entry at 1122 King Rd. Moscow, Idaho. Also under the first entry, fill in the #of other items (10) collected in the other tests / items panel Should the information about processing for latents / footwear with powder and amido be added to the report? And that L1-L6 were developed and preserved? Information Verified yes Verified By: Jennifer (Jennie) Ayers Date Reviewed by Accompanying 03/08/2023 Responder C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ FS_MATRIX.rpt Page 2 of 3 014927 22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 32 FIELD SERVICES ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of Analysis: - 8/14/2023 Notes from Accompanying JA 02/15/23: Responder I added notes as requested by post its, and made notes on others. BPA pages and window lock page should be at end of house notes. In the report, in the descriptions of the bedrooms, put details in past tense (door open, location of items). In reference to LizQ, change to LizQ imaging system. BPA documentation in both bedrooms not included in report. I would maybe say something like " I photographed the approximate size and location of bloodstains and / or groups of bloodstains, in two bedrooms. In the second floor west bedroom, bloodstains labeled AA-AG were documented. In the third floor east bedroom, bloodstains labeled BA-BL were documented. " LP processing (chemical and powder) is not included in report, nor are the results. I would describe both generally by location, since details are in notes. I would only include victim names in header of report, as they were the only names we knew for sure for associated people at the time we were at the scene. 02/27/23 In powder processing paragraph, I would modify " Six latent lift cards (L1 and L2)... " to " (latents L1 and L2) ". In amido black paragraph " L3-L6 were collected via photography, of the following... " I would modify to " Latents L3-L6... " and " via photography from the following: ". Should " amido black " be capitalized? Information Verified yes Verified By: Kerry Hogan Date Reviewed by Accompanying 03/01/2023 Responder Notes from Accompanying ΚΚΗ 2/28: Responder 1122 King road info: -Paragraph one, sentence one is missing the time we responded (should be 0845) -Blood testing paragraph: " north wall of kitchen (ISP D2 marker 40), kitchen cabinet, under kitchen cabinet, kitchen sink " should be " on floor under north wall cupboards (ISP D2 marker 40), kitchen cabinet, and kitchen sink " 1127 King road info: -Blood testing paragraph: for marker 1, " on the south wall of entry hallway (marker 1) -marker 2 was the east wall (my apologies on that, I have corrected the notes) Information Verified yes Verified By: Wyatt Barie Date Reviewed by Accompanying 03/01/2023 Responder Notes from Accompanying WAB 2/22/23: Responder Should # of captures and sphericals be 42 since there was a high and low taken at every location? (resulting in 2 for each of the 21 locations). LizQ Imaging Task Value LizQ Imaging Location 1122 King Road, Moscow, ID # of Captures 42 # of sphericals 42 LizQ Total Images Captured 4158 General Notes First floor: 178-185; second floor: 186-204; Staircase between floor 2 and 3: 205-206; third floor: 207-216; front driveway: 217-218; back yard: 219-220. C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ FS_MATRIX.rpt Page 3 of 3 014928 22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 32 ISPFS CRIME SCENE RESPONSE Call out received date: 11/16/22 time: by: Jennie Ayers Location: 112-2 KING RD MUSEON ID Agency: mosCOW PD Agency Case # 1022000030 MISCON PD Search Warrant obtained? Y / N: / 22-M09903 Details: DumpsTERS WOLED THROULITH Incident Date: ALSO LED THROUGH. PER DET ALREADY HOUSE TRASH CANS TAURNTT. 2ND FLOOR BATHROOM TRASH CENTAINED BLUE LATEX-TMPO GLOVES + TISSUE W / DROP OF BLOED PER TAUBTT GUNES COMETED ART SLIDER ALWAYS OPEN (UNLOCKED). DRONT DOOR AUTO-ICKS, PEOPLE HANS COOLE TO GET * any additional requests IN for processing shall be documented in the case notes * DUT ******************************************************** TALBOTT CROWED FRONT DOOR レイン し た うさ 10 ********* T 11/16/22 ****: ***** ISPFS Personnel: Jennie Ayers Date: Hailey Youngling, Whatt Barie, Enroute: 1452 MST Tara martinez, Kom Hogan Arrived: 2012 MST 1912 PST Crime Homicide Clear: (@ISP D2) Type: Back to ISPFS: 리리 123 ISPFS Lab #: M 2022 4843 wint Scene AM3 13 23 Security: [] entry log [barrier tape [Fficer (s) posted Weather: Snow / Rain / Windy / Clear / Cloudy / Cold / Hot Temperature: ~ 30 ° F Briefed by: Walk through: (time Officers / Detectives Present: DET. TALBOTT (ISP D2).) Victim / Suspect / Subject: KAYLEE GONCALVES Victim / Suspect / Subject: MADISON MOGEN DOB: Victim / Suspect / Subject: XANA KERNODLE DOB: Victim / Suspect / Subject: ETHAN CHHAPIN DOB: DOB: Vehicle (s): Coroner: Arrival: Mortuary: Arrival: Body bag seal #: Photography Presumptive Blood test (s) () Trace Evidence [] Video Blood enhancement Footwear / Tire Tracks [] Sketch [] Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Latent Print Processing [] Location / Dimensions [] Shooting Reconstruction [] Major Case Prints [] ALS exam (note unit & nm) []] Firearms Evidence 23 [] A LizQ [] 07 [] 1922 3374 5890 TOTAL 3874 2718 One Digital images numbered 7915 to Digital images uploaded to 10 Foray 11 20 22 TM + HMY [Digital images provided to agency via: digital transfer thumb drive / CD / DVD 11/19/22 [] Results @Da office-Dei. Talbott @ 0838 of processing / chemical