Court Filing
IDAHO POLICE - STATE - IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES 700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202 Phone: (208) 884-7170 Fax: (208) 884-7197 FORENSIC BIOLOGY REPORT Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s).: Laboratory Case No.: MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843 Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.: 11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 16 Date Evidence Accepted: Analyst: 12/28/2022 Katherine Dace Case Name (s): Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION: Item 79: Two band-aids and two paper peels from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 79.1: Cutting from one band-aid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 80: Black straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 80.1: Swab of black straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 81: Two pink earplugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 81.1: Swab of two pink earplugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 82: Five lollipop sticks & two wrappers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 82.1: Lollipop stick one Item 82.1.1: Cutting from lollipop stick 1 from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 82.2: Lollipop stick two Item 82.2.1: Cutting from lollipop stick 2 from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 82.3: Lollipop stick three Item 82.4: Lollipop stick four Item 82.5: Lollipop stick five Item 83: Nail clippers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 83.1: Swab of stain on nail clippers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 84: Eight ear plugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 85: Used napkins from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 86: Six green CVS flossers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 86.1: Cutting from one flosser from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 87: Three Q-tip style swabs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 87.1: Cutting from one Q-tip style swab from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 88: Dunkin Donut cup & lid with straw holder (no straw) and empty Stevia packet from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 89: Orange and pink straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 89.1: Swab of orange and pink straw 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 90: Flossers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA STATE'S EXHIBIT exhibitsticker.com Item 91: Q-Tips from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA S-16 (b) 005662 Page 1 of 3 Case No. CR01-24-31665 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 16 Item 92: Lollipop stick from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 93: Dunkin cup with lid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 93.1: Swab of cup lid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 94: Popsicle sticks from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 95: Eleven water bottles and four caps from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 95.1: Bowl and Basket water bottle Item 95.2: Bowl and Basket water bottle Item 95.3: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.4: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.5: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.5.1: Swab of Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 95.6: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.7: Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.8: Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.9: Poland Springs water bottle with cap Item 95.9.1: Swab of Poland Spring water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 95.10: Crumpled Poland Springs water bottle Item 95.11: Crumpled Poland Springs water bottle with cap Item 95.12: Four loose caps Item 96: Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 96.1: Swab of Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS: Results from presumptive chemical tests performed on Item 83 indicated the presence of blood. Items 79, 82.1, 82.2, 86, and 87 were examined only for the purpose of sampling for DNA analysis. Items 80, 81, 89, 93, 95.5, 95.9, and 96 were swabbed for DNA collection. Items 88, 95.1 through 95.4, 95.6 through 95.8, and 95.10 through 95.12 were visually examined, however no further analysis was performed. Items 84, 85, 90, 91, 92, and 94 were not examined. DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE: Items 79.1, 80.1, 81.1, 82.1.1, 82.2.1, 83.1, 86.1, 87.1, 89.1, 93.1, 95.5.1, 95.9.1, and 96.1 were forwarded for DNA analysis. Results will follow in a separate report. All remaining items have been returned to the main laboratory evidence vault pending DNA analysis. REMARKS: The descriptions, conclusions and interpretations stated above apply to the sample (s) as received. I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct. Kathorne Dace Katherine Dace / Forensic Scientist 005663 Page 2 of 3 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 16 Issue Date: 12/28/2022 005664 Page 3 of 3 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 General Analysis Item 79-Two band-aids and two paper peels from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 79... 1A... two (2) band-aids (agency case # not listed) Contents Description / Notes Contains two band aids stuck together and two paper strips (paper strips not examined or itemized). Band-aids separated for photo. No blood-like staining noted. ~ 5mm2 cutting taken from fabric of one band aid for DNA (79.1). Other band aid not sampled at this time. Repack, ets. Item 79.1-Cutting from one band-aid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 80-Black straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 80... 1B... straw (agency case # not listed) Contents Description / Notes Contains one black straw. Some possible food-like staining present, more heavily concentrated on end 1 of straw. Both ends of straw swabbed together with one swab (80.1). Entire swab cut for DNA. Repack, ets. Item 80.1-Swab of black straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 81-Two pink earplugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed Yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 81... 1C... two (2) pink ear plugs... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains two pink ear plugs. Items have debris stuck to outside (possible coffee grounds). Entire surface area of both ear plugs swabbed together with one swab (81.1). Entire swab cut for DNA. Repack, ets. C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 1 of 7 005665 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Item 81.1-Swab of two pink earplugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 82-Item 82: Five lollipop sticks & two wrappers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 82.1: Lollipop stick one Item 82.2: Lollipop stick two Item 82.3: Lollipop stick three Item 82.4: Lollipop stick four Item 82.5: Lollipop stick five Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 82... 1D... lollipop sticks & wrappers... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains 5 lollipop sticks and two Starburst wrappers (wrappers not examined). Sticks subitemed 82.1 through 82.5. One stick has apparent hair stuck to one end (left in place). Cuttings taken from 82.1 and 82.2 (designated 82.1.1 and 82.2.1 respectively). Remaining sticks not examined. Sticks marked 1-5 with marker. Repack, ets. Item 82.1.1-Cutting from lollipop stick 1 from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 82.2.1-Cutting from lollipop stick 2 from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 83-Nail clippers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 83... 1D... nail clippers... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains one pair of silver nail clippers, Has yellow and white staining on clipping end, staining flakes off very easily. Also has some reddish staining on handle end, staining is OTOL +. All of staining swabbed with one swab (83.1). Entire swab consumed for DNA. Clipping end not swabbed at this time. Repack, ets. O-Tol positive Item 83.1-Swab of stain on nail clippers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 2 of 7 005666 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 84-Eight ear plugs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843... 84... 1D... eight (8) ear plugs... 22-M09903 Item 85-Used napkins from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843... 85... 2B... used napkin... 22-M09903 Item 86-Six green CVS flossers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843.86.2B... Flosser... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains 6 green CVS brand flossers. Flossers appear used. Floss cut from one flosser (86.1). Remaining flossers not examined. Repack, ets. Item 86.1-Cutting from one flosser from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 87-Three Q-tip style swabs from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 87... 2B... Q-tip... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains 3 Q-tip style swabs w / yellow-brown staining. One apparent hair is present, left in place. One end of one swab cut for DNA (87.1). repack, ets. Item 87.1-Cutting from one Q-tip style swab from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 3 of 7 005667 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 88-Dunkin Donut cup & lid with straw holder (no straw) and empty Stevia packet from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging brown paper bag Package Labeling M2022-4843... 88... 2C... Dunkin donut cup with lid..22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains one Dunkin cup, separate plastic lid w / straw hole, and one empty Stevia packet. Lid is designed to be used with straw and not drank from directly. Item not sampled at this time. Repack, ets. Item 89-Orange and pink straw from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843.89.2C.straw... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains one orange and pink straw. Has apparent coffee grounds on outside. Some food-like staining noted on surface. Both ends swabbed with one swab (89.1). Entire swab cut for DNA. Repack, ets. Item 89.1-Swab of orange and pink straw 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 90-Flossers from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843.90.3B... Flossers... 22-M09903 Note: Envelope was placed in plastic sleeve at intake due to wetness of envelope Item 91-Q - Tips from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 4 of 7 005668 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 5 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843... 91... 3C... Qtip... 22-M09903 Item 92-Lollipop stick from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843... 92... 3C... lollipop stick... 22-M09903 Item 93-Dunkin cup with lid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging brown paper bag Package Labeling M2022-4843... 93... 3C..Dunkin cup with lid... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains one Dunkin cup with plastic lid. Plastic lid has mouth area and lid seal. Mouth area of lid and underside of lid seal swabbed with one swab. Entire swab cut for DNA (93.1). Repack, ets. Item 93.1-Swab of cup lid from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 94-Popsicle sticks from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope No Exam X Package Labeling M2022-4843... 94... 4B... popsicle sticks... 22-M09903 C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 5 of 7 005669 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 6 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Item 95-Item 95: Eleven water bottles and four caps from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Item 95.1: Bowl and Basket water bottle Item 95.2: Bowl and Basket water bottle Item 95.3: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.4: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.5: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.6: Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.7: Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.8: Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle with cap Item 95.9: Poland Springs water bottle with cap Item 95.10: Crumpled Poland Springs water bottle Item 95.11: Crumpled Poland Springs water bottle with cap Item 95.12: Four loose caps Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging brown paper bag Package Labeling M2022-4843... 95..3B..water bottles and caps... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains 11 water bottles: 2 Poland Springs brand water bottles w / cap on, 1 Poland Springs brand water bottle w / no cap on, 6 Bowl and Basket brand water bottles w / cap on, and 2 Bowl and Basket brand water bottles w / no cap on. 4 loose caps also present in bag. Bottles itemized as 95.1 through 95.11. Caps itemized as 95.12. Items 95.5 and 95.9 selected for sampling. For each, mouth area of bottle and inside of cap swabbed with one swab (95.5.1 and 95.9.1 respectively). Each swab cut for DNA. All water bottles marked with item # on bottom. Loose caps not labeled. Repack, ets. Item 95.5.1-Swab of Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 95.9.1-Swab of Poland Spring water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 96-Crumpled Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 12/28/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging evidence envelope Package Labeling M2022-4843... 96... 4E..water bottle... 22-M09903 Contents Description / Notes Contains one crumpled Bowl and Basket brand water bottle w / cap. Appears to have coffee grounds on outer surface. Mouth area of bottle and inside of cap swabbed w / one swab (96.1). Entire swab cut for DNA. repack, ets. C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 6 of 7 005670 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 7 of 19 BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Katherine Dace Dates of analysis: 12/28/2022 to 12/28/2022 Item 96.1-Swab of Bowl and Basket water bottle and cap from 127 Parkside Ave, Blakeslee, PA Task / Test Value Retained Yes Item Source Q Screening Analysis Controls Task / Test Value Date 12/28/2022 O-Tol Lot # O-TOL051822 O-Tol (+) blue / green O-Tol (-) no reaction C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 7 of 7 005671 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 8 of 19 cutting taken for DNA (79.1) RETRIC 3 4 5 10 11 12 13 14 15 ⊕ ८ SEHONI M2022-4843 79 12/28/22 13 005672 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 9 of 19 Swabbed for DNA (80.1) End 1 End 2 METRIC 10 11 12 13 14 ⊕ SEHONI M2022 4843 80 12/28/22 KO 005673 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 10 of 19 entire surface area swabbed = (81.1) METRIC 10 11 12 13 14 15 ⊕ SHONI M2022-4843 81 12/28 122 13 005674 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 11 of 19 82.1 Starburs oranee 82.2 CHE LECIT 82.3 Pops SYOUR ARTIFI SUNBLOWER REDIENTS OIL & ) 17 (Gran CORN KERNEL NATURAL 10 AN LA PALA LATIN 640) FOOD YABOGENA RED 82.4 MAS Down DUATIN YELLOW ( WT) sood ange 82.5 NET 17 (ANGLER F orange S S METRIC 10 12 13 14 15 ⊕ = cut for DNA INCHES (82.1.1 and 82.2.1 respectively) M2022-4843 82 12/28/22 143 005675 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 12 of 19 area swabbed for DNA (83.1) OTOL + METRIC 10 12 13 14 15 ⊕ M2022-4843 83 12/28/22 13 005676 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 13 of 19 CVS Cut for DNA (86.1) GVS METRIC 10 12 13 14 SEHONI M2022-4843 86 12128122 KO 005677 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 14 of 19 Cut for DNA (87.1) METRIC 10 12 13 14 15 SHONI M2022-4843 87 12/28/22 1 005678 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 15 of 19 LIFE IS SWEETER WITH FRIENDS stributed GREDIENTS by STEVIA LEAF EXTRACTATURAL WT LEZZAARVE FLAV DUNKIN METRIC ⊕ SHONI M2022-4843 88 12/28122 m 005679 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 16 of 19 Swabbed for DNA (89.1) METRIC ⊕ M2022-4843 89 12/28/22 1m 005680 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 17 of 19 LOC THERMOGUARD mouth area of lid and underside of seal swabbed for DNA (93.1) FOR OPTIMA 224PP METRIC 1 10 11 12 15 ⊕ SHONI M2022-4843 93. 12/28/22 m 005681 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 18 of 19 mouth area of bottle and inside of lid swabbed (95.5.1) bowl basket & 95.7 95.8 95.12 mouth area of bottle and inside of lid swabbed (95.9.1) basket bowl & basket bowl & basket. Poland Spring &. NG WATER & basket. owl & basket 3 WATER & basket. Poland Spring P Sig A 95.4 95.5 95.6 95.9 95.10 95.11 95.1 95.2 95.3 M2022-4843 95 12/28/22 क 005682 22-M09903 # 16 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 19 of 19 : • NO BPA ADDED 0 * Bdtles Without are BPA manufactured added 4119006 Empty & NYSHD CT how ow-NY bowl swabbed for DNA (96.1) ? Ce 5 A SPRIN HOPRITE & & BRANDnet 15.9 FL యి OZ ( Prismal @ METRIC 15 SHONI M2022-4845 96 12 / 28 / 221m 005683 IDAHO POLICE- STATE IDAHO STATE POL