Court Filing
The 20 most-mentioned. The full list is in the case file.
IDAHO POLICE- STATE - IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES 700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202 Phone: (208) 884-7170 Fax: (208) 884-7197 FORENSIC BIOLOGY REPORT Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s).: Laboratory Case No.: MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843 Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.: 11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 1 Date Evidence Accepted: Analyst: 11/16/2022 Stephanie Wilt Case Name (s): Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION: Item 1: KA-BAR knife sheath Item 1.1: Swab of front strap Item 1.2: Swab of edges on handle portion Item 1.3: Swab of edges on blade portion Item 1.4: Swabs of stains on back CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS: Results from presumptive chemical tests performed on Item 1 indicated the presence of blood. Item 1 was swabbed for DNA collection. Trace evidence was collected from Item 1, but was not examined at this time. Known reference samples from Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, Ethan Chapin, and Kaylee Goncalves are required for DNA comparison. Please contact the laboratory regarding the status of these known reference samples. A known reference sample from any developed suspect (s) is required for DNA comparison. Please contact the laboratory regarding the status of this known reference sample. DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE: Items 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, and 1.4 were forwarded for DNA analysis. Results will follow in a separate report. Item 1 was left in the custody of Forensic Scientist Tina Walthall pending latent fingerprint processing. The empty packaging for Items 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, and 1.4 has been returned to the main laboratory evidence vault pending DNA analysis. STATE'S EXHIBIT exhibitsticker.com 000265 S-24 (b) Page 1 of 2 Case No. CR01-24-31665 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 1 REMARKS: The descriptions, conclusions and interpretations stated above apply to the sample (s) as received. I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct. Stghui Walt Stephanie Wilt / Forensic Scientist Issue Date: 11/18/2022 000266 Page 2 of 2 IDAHO POLICE- STATE IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES 700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202 Phone: (208) 884-7170 Fax: (208) 884-7197 FORENSIC BIOLOGY REPORT Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s).: Laboratory Case No.: MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843 Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.: 11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 3 Date Evidence Accepted: Analyst: 11/18/2022 Stephanie Wilt Case Name (s): Suspect-JACK S DUCOEUR Subject-BETHANY G FUNKE Subject-DYLAN M MORTENSEN Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION: Item 3: Submitted swab from F2 bedroom floor Item 4: Submitted swab and debris from F3 bedroom floor Item 6: Right fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Item 6.1: Swab of right fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Item 7: Left fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Item 7.1: Swab of left fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Item 9: Right fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Item 9.1: Swab of right fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Item 10: Left fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Item 10.1: Swab of left fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Item 12: Right fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Item 12.1: Swab of right fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Item 13: Left fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Item 13.1: Swab of left fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Item 15: Right fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Item 15.1: Swab of right fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Item 16: Left fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Item 16.1: Swab of left fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Page 1 of 2 000492 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 3 CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS: Results from presumptive chemical tests performed on Items 3, 6, 7, 9, 10, 12, 13, 15, 16, and the swab from Item 4 indicated the presence of blood. Results from presumptive chemical tests for the presence of blood were negative on the debris from Item 4. DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE: Items 6.1, 7.1, 13.1, 15.1, 16.1, and the swab from Item 4, and a portion of Items 3, 9.1, 10.1, and 12.1 were forwarded for DNA analysis. Results will follow in a separate report. All remaining items and the empty packaging for Items 4, 6.1, 7.1, 13.1, 15.1, and 16.1 have been returned to the main laboratory evidence vault pending DNA analysis. REMARKS: The descriptions, conclusions and interpretations stated above apply to the sample (s) as received. I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct. Styhui Walt Stephanie Wilt / Forensic Scientist Issue Date: 11/19/2022 Page 2 of 2 000493 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 13 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/19/2022 to 11/19/2022 General Analysis Item 10-Left fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clippings L... Kernodle, Xana Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings. Obs red-brown staining on all nails. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 10.1, red-brown transfer to swab, poss consumptive). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 10.1-Swab of left fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes ~ 1 / 2 of stained portion cut to DNA, remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 12-Right fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clippings R... Mogen, Madison Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings. Obs red-brown staining on all nails, and light pink stain on exterior of largest clipping. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 12.1, red-brown transfer to swab; note: avoided light pink stain; and broke 1 nail during swabbing). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 12.1-Swab of right fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes ~ 1 / 2 of stained portion cut to DNA, remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 13-Left fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 1 of 5 000494 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 13 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/19/2022 to 11/19/2022 Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clippings L... Mogen, Madison Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings. Obs light red-brown staining on all nails. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 13.1, light red-brown transfer to swab, consumptive; note: broke 2 nails during swabbing). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 13.1-Swab of left fingernail clippings from Madison Mogen Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Whole stained portion of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 15-Right fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clipping R... Goncalves, Kaylee Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings. Obs red-brown staining on all nails and orange stain on interior of largest clipping. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 15.1, light red-brown transfer to swab, consumptive; note: broke 2 nails during swabbing and some stains remaining). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 15.1-Swab of right fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Whole stained portion of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 16-Left fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 2 of 5 000495 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 13 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/19/2022 to 11/19/2022 Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clipping L... Goncalves, Kaylee Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings. Obs light red-brown staining on all nails. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 16.1, light red-brown transfer to swab, consumptive; note: broke 2 nails during swabbing and some stains remaining). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 16.1-Swab of left fingernail clippings from Kaylee Goncalves Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Whole stained portion of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 3-Submitted swab from F2 bedroom floor Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... blood swab Prelogged in part as: collected from F2 bedroom floor Contents Description / Notes Swab box cont'g 1 dark red-brown swab. Tested swab (= o-tol pos). ~ 1 / 3 of swab cut to DNA. Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 4-Submitted swab and debris from F3 bedroom floor Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... blood swab Prelogged in part as: taken from F3 bedroom floor Contents Description / Notes Swab box cont'g off-white swab and red-brown debris. Tested swab (= o-tol wk pos) and debris (= o-tol neg). Swab appears consumptive. Repack, ets. Re-accessed same day, PTC received. Whole swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab stick repack, ets. O-Tol Weak positive Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 6-Right fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 3 of 5 000496 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 13 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/19/2022 to 11/19/2022 Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Rt nail clipping... Chapin, Ethan Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g five fingernail clippings and clipping debris. Obs light red-brown staining on nails. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 6.1, light red-brown transfer to swab, consumptive). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 6.1-Swab of right fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Whole stained portion of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 7-Left fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Lft nail clipping... Chapin, Ethan Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g four fingernail clippings. Obs red-brown staining on three clippings. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 7.1, red-brown transfer to swab, consumptive). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 7.1-Swab of left fingernail clippings from Ethan Chapin Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Whole stained portion of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 9-Right fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging small manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Nail clippings R... Kernodle, Xana C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 4 of 5 000497 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 5 of 13 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/19/2022 to 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes Glassine paper cont'g four fingernail clippings. Obs red-brown staining on all nails. Tested 1 total stain (= o-tol pos). Used 1 swab to swab nail clippings (= Item 9.1, red-brown transfer to swab, poss consumptive). Repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item 9.1-Swab of right fingernail clippings from Xana Kernodle Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/19/2022 Contents Description / Notes ~ 1 / 2 of stained portion cut to DNA, remaining swab pack in man env, ets. Retained Yes Item Source Q Screening Analysis Controls Task / Test Value Date 11/19/2022 O-Tol Lot # O-TOL051822 O-Tol (+) blue / green O-Tol (-) no reaction C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 5 of 5 000498 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 6 of 13 SAW M2022-4843 Item 6 11/19/22 Saw 2 5 INCH U.S.A. 12 11 10 9 8 5 4 3 12 CM 15 14 13 O-tol = Area Swabbed (= Item (6.1) 000499 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 7 of 13 SHW 2 3 4 U.S.A. 3 2 LV CM 13 12 11 10 6 8 7 9 5 4 M2022-4843 Item 7 11/19/22 Saw O-tol -Area swabbed (Item 7.1) 000500 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 8 of 13 3 5 9 U.S.A. 14 13 12 11 10 19 8 יויייייייייייין 7 6 5 34 M2022-4843 Item 9 11/19/22 Saw otol (+) = Area Swabbed (Item 9.1) ( 000501 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 9 of 13 लह 2 3 4 5 14 13 12 11 10 6 8 7 9 5 ייייייייייייי M2022-4843 Item 10 11/19/22 Saw O-tol Q = Area Swabbed (= Item 10.1) 000502 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 10 of 13 2 3 5 U.S.A. 67 45 23 1 см 13 12 11 10 6 8 M2022-4843 Item 12 11/19/22 Jaw O-tol = Area swabbed (= Item 12.1) 000503 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 11 of 13 2 3 4 5 6 S 13 12 11 10 6 8 7 9 5 4 3 2 1 CM M2022-4843 Item 13 11/19/22 Saw Otol = Area Swabbed (= Item 13.1) 000504 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 12 of 13 SAW 2 3 4 5 U.S.A. 3 2 1 CM 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 M2022-4843 Item 15 Otol 11/19/22 Saw ○ = Area swabbed (= Item 15.1) 000505 22-M09903 # 3 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 13 of 13 SAW 3 4 5 2 U.S.A. 45 3 2 1 CM 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 M2022-4843 Item 116 11/19/22 Jaw o-tol + = Area swabbed (= Item 16.1) 000506 IDAHO POLICE STATE IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES 700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202 Phone: (208) 884-7170 Fax: (208) 884-7197 FORENSIC BIOLOGY REPORT Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s).: Laboratory Case No.: MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843 Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.: 11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 8 Date Evidence Accepted: Analyst: 11/21/2022 Stephanie Wilt Case Name (s): Suspect-JACK S DUCOEUR Subject-BETHANY G FUNKE Subject-DYLAN M MORTENSEN Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION: Item 23: Submitted swab from above stairwell Item 24: Submitted swab from upper floor banister Item 29: Submitted swabs from outside of south kitchen window Item 29.1: Submitted swab of face mark Item 29.2: Submitted swab of hand marks Item 29.3: Submitted swab of finger mark Item 30: Submitted swab of stain on bottom of handrail Item 31: Submitted swabs of stains on half wall Item 31.1: Submitted swab of stain on edge of half wall Item 31.2: Submitted swab of stain on top of half wall CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS: Results from presumptive chemical tests performed on Items 23 and 24 indicated the presence of blood. Items 29.1, 29.2, 29.3, 30, and 31.1 were examined only for the purpose of sampling for DNA analysis. Item 31.2 was not examined. Page 1 of 2 000507 Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 8 DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE: Items 23, 29.1, 29.2, 29.3, 30, 31.1, and a portion of Item 24 were forwarded for DNA analysis. Results will follow in a separate report. All remaining items and the empty packaging for Items 23, 29, and 30 have been returned to the main laboratory evidence vault pending DNA analysis. REMARKS: The descriptions, conclusions and interpretations stated above apply to the sample (s) as received. I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct. Shui Welt Stephanie Wilt / Forensic Scientist Issue Date: 11/28/2022 Page 2 of 2 000508 22-M09903 # 8 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 3 SAW BIOLOGY ANALYSIS NOTES Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Stephanie Wilt Dates of analysis: 11/23/2022 to 11/23/2022 General Analysis Item 23-Submitted swab from above stairwell Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/23/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Item 21 Blood swab Prelogged in part as: from above stairwell Contents Description / Notes Swab box cont'g one light red-brown swab with staining concentrated to one side. Tested swab (= o-tol pos). Whole stained portion cut to DNA (~ 1 / 2 of swab remaining). Remaining swab repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 24-Submitted swab from upper floor banister Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/23/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Item 35 Blood swab Prelogged in part as: from upper floor banister Contents Description / Notes Swab box cont'g one dark red-brown swab. Tested swab (= o-tol pos). ~ 1 / 3 of swab cut to DNA. Remaining swab repack, ets. O-Tol Positive Retained Yes Item Source Q Item 29-Submitted swabs from outside of south kitchen window Task / Test Value Date of Analysis 11/23/2022 Seal evidence tape Initialed yes Packaging manila envelope Package Labeling 22-M09903... Swabs of poss finger / hand and face marks... Outside south kitchen window Contents Description / Notes Three ets coin man env: one labeled Swab of face mark on outside of south kitchen window... Marker 7 (= Item 29.1); one labeled Swab of hand marks on outside of south kitchen window... Marker 8 (= Item 29.2); and one labeled Swab of finger mark on outside of south kitchen window... Marker 9 (= Item 29.3). Repack, ets. Retained Yes Item 29.1-Submitted swab of face mark Task / Test Value C: \ inetpub \ wwwroot \ ILIMS \ Reports \ MSSQL \ BIO_MATRIX.rpt Page 1 of 3 000509 22-M09903 # 28 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 13 of 33 SHW Front M2022-4843 Item 113 02/13/23 Jaw o-tol (-) Top Left Right O-tol (-) Bottom INCHES 1 2 3 5 6 191 ει 11 OL 6 8 9 ε 2 L 009288 22-M09903 # 28 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 14 of 33 SHW Back M2022-4843 Item 113 02/13/23 Saw O-tol (-) Top Right 583 75BRC o-tol (-) Left Bottom 4 5 6 3 INCHES ⊕ 4 3 2 1 METRIC 12 11 10 6 8 7 15 14 13 009289 22-M09903 # 28 M2022-4843 MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 15 of 33 SHW Front M2022-4843 o-tol (-) Item 114 02/13/