State Exhibit S 18b Martinez Part 1

IDAHO

POLICE

STATE

IDAHO STATE POLICE FORENSIC SERVICES

700 South Stratford Drive, Ste 125 Meridian, ID 83642-6202
Phone: (208) 884-7170
Fax: (208) 884-7197
FORENSIC LATENT PRINT EXAMINATION REPORT

Case Agency (s): Agency Case No (s).: Laboratory Case No.:
MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT 22-M09903 M2022-4843

Date (s) of Offense: Investigating Officer (s): Report No.:
11/13/2022 Dustin Blaker 5
Date Evidence Accepted: Analyst:
11/18/2022, 11/21/2022 Tara Martinez Case Name (s):
Suspect-JACK S DUCOEUR Subject-BETHANY G FUNKE Subject-DYLAN M MORTENSEN Victim-MADISON M MOGEN Victim-XANA A KERNODLE Victim-ETHAN J CHAPIN Victim-KAYLEE J GONCALVES
EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION:

Item 21: Digital images for comparison captured at 1122 King Rd. Moscow, Idaho Item 25 (Agency Exh. 22M-1909): four exemplars bearing the name Ethan J. Chapin (25.1-25.4).

Item 26 (Agency Exh. 22M-1950): four exemplars bearing the name Xana Kernodle (26.1-26.4).

Item 27 (Agency Exh. 22M-1987): four exemplars bearing the name Madison Mogen (27.1-27.4).

Item 28 (Agency Exh. 22M-2024): four exemplars bearing the name Kaylee Goncalve (28.1-28.4).

CONCLUSIONS AND INTERPRETATIONS:

One latent print was examined for comparable ridge detail.

Latent print L5 is of value for comparison. Latent print L5 is of value for Multi-Modal Biometric Identification System (MBIS) inquiry.

Latent prints of value were analyzed and compared to the known exemplars bearing the names MADISON MOGEN, KAYLEE GONCALVE, XANA KERNODLE and ETHAN J CHAPIN.

Latent print L5 was entered and searched through MBIS where no likely candidates were generated.

Page 1 of 2 STATE'S EXHIBIT exhibitsticker.com S-18 (b) 000851 Case No. CR01-24-31665

Laboratory Case Number: M2022-4843 Report No.: 5
COMPARISON RESULTS:

Latent Print MADISON ΧΑΝΑ ETHAN KAYLEE
MOGEN KERNODLE CHAPIN GONCALVES

L5 Excluded INCE INCE Excluded INCE in the table above indicates that the comparison is inconclusive to the available exemplars. The inconclusive result is due to a lack of quantity / quality of detail in the known exemplars.

Excluded in the table above indicates that the latent print is excluded to the exemplars used.

No fingerprints were found to be on file for JACK DUCOEUR, BETHANY FUNKE and DYLAN MORTENSEN.

In order to complete the comparison portion of this examination, it is requested that a quality set of fingerprints be submitted.

If a suspect is developed by your agency at a later date, a fingerprint card or the appropriate suspect information should be submitted for comparison.

There are three remaining latent prints captured from 1122 King Rd. (L1, L2 and L6); additional report to follow.

DISPOSITION OF EVIDENCE:

Latent prints were marked and preserved. Digital images used for analysis and / or comparison are being retained by ISP Forensic Services.

Items 25-28 are being retained in the laboratory, pending further comparisons.

Digital evidence will not be returned to the submitting agency.

REMARKS:

The descriptions, conclusions and interpretations stated above apply to the sample (s) as received.

I declare under penalty of perjury pursuant to the law of the State of Idaho that the foregoing is true and correct.

Jau my Tara Martinez / Forensic Scientist
Issue Date: 11/28/2022 Page 2 of 2 000852

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 1 of 37
LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES

URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 11/20/2022 to 11/28/2022 Packaging Information
Agency Item # 22M-1909 Desc: Major Crime Prints for victim Ethan Chapin from autopsy.

Lab Item # 25 Desc: four exemplars bearing the name Ethan J. Chapin (25.1-25.4) Task / Test Value Date Opened 11/22/2022 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Packaging Notes Items held in a clear zip top bag. Tissue type paper (2 sheets) and a black piece of construction type paper are present in envelope.

Agency Item # 22M-1950 Desc: Major Crime Prints for victim Xana Kernodle from autopsy.

Lab Item # 26 Desc: four exemplars bearing the name Xana Kernodle (26.1-26.4) Task / Test Value Date Opened 11/22/2022 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Packaging Notes Items held in a clear zip top bag. Also present in envelope are black construction type paper (2).

Agency Item # 22M-1987 Desc: Major Crime Prints for victim Madison Mogen from autopsy.

Lab Item # 27 Desc: four exemplars bearing the name Madison Mogen (27.1-27.4) Task / Test Value Date Opened 11/22/2022 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Packaging Notes Items held in a clear zip top bag. Also present in envelope are black construction type paper (2). Some exemplars have Mogen spelled with an a " Mogan ".

Agency Item # 22M-2024 Desc: Major Crime Prints for victim Kaylee Goncalves from autopsy.

Lab Item # 28 Desc: four exemplars bearing the name Kaylee Goncalve (28.1-28.4) Task / Test Value Date Opened 11/22/2022 Sealed Yes Initialed Yes External Packaging Type manila envelope Packaging Notes Items held in a clear zip top bag. Also present in envelope are black construction type paper (2). Some exemplars have last name as " Goncalve " and others have " Gonclave " Latent Analysis Task / Test Value Latent # or Lift # L5 Date 11/20/2022 Orientation Known? Yes Anatomic Source Finger NV Impressions Present Pattern Source side with delta-left loop? could be a whorl Clarity 1, 2, and 3 Complex No Pressure Medium Distortion areas of higher pressure or excess amido. smears. some surface lines.

Dev. Medium amido black Substrate plastic-slider door in kitchen of house-facing kitchen (interior) Preservation Digital image Page 1 of 5 000853

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 2 of 37
LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES

URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 11/20/2022 to 11/28/2022 Comparison Value Yes MBIS Quality Yes Examiner Notes Crime scene images 5840 and 5841 No points of correspondence to Chapin but # 9 finger is hard to see delta. No full palms w / fingers recorded; INCE. TM 11/22/22 No points of correspondence to Kernodle but # 6 finger is hard to see delta. No full palms w / fingers recorded; INCE. TM 11/22/22 No points of correspondence to Mogen but # 10 finger is hard to see delta. No full palms w / fingers recorded; INCE. TM 11/22/22 Re-compared latent to Mogen, agree that there is no correspondence above core; EXC. TM 11/22/22
Verified Yes Verifier: Hailey Youngling Verified Date 11/23/2022 Verifier Notes INCE Kernodle- # 6 delta / side area not clear, need better recording INCE Chapin- # 4 and # 9 delta / side area not clear, need better recording EXC Goncalves I think area above delta is different enough on Mogen # 10 to exclude.

EXC Mogen Digital images stored in Digital images stored in Foray / Adams Web Foray / Adams Web Exemplars Task / Test Value Exemplar Name MADISON M MOGEN Name on Card (if different) MADISON MOGEN Exemplar Identifier Items 27.1-27.4 Type of Card Major Case Quality of Exemplar Medium-High Recorded By LE and Clb Recorded Date 11/17/2022 Recorded Agency Spokane County Sheriff's Office Obtained From Agency Exemplar Notes finger rolls, palms and feet Task / Test Value Exemplar Name ΧΑΝΑ Α ΚERNODLE Name on Card (if different) XANA KERNODLE Exemplar Identifier Items 26.1-26.4 Type of Card Major Case Quality of Exemplar Medium-High Recorded By S. Micke and L. Estridge Recorded Date 11/16/2022 Recorded Agency Spokane County Sheriff's Office Obtained From Agency Exemplar Notes finger rolls, palms and feet Task / Test Value Exemplar Name ETHAN J CHAPIN Exemplar Identifier Items 25.1-25.4 Type of Card Finger and Palm Quality of Exemplar High Recorded By T. Boniecki Recorded Date 11/16/2022 Recorded Agency Spokane County Sheriff's Office Page 2 of 5 000854

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 3 of 37
LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES

URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 11/20/2022 to 11/28/2022 Obtained From Agency Task / Test Value Exemplar Name KAYLEE J GONCALVES Name on Card (if different) KAYLEE GONCALVE Exemplar Identifier Items 28.1-28.4 Type of Card Major Case Quality of Exemplar Medium-High Recorded By Clb and LE Recorded Date 11/17/2022 Recorded Agency Spokane County Sheriff's Office Obtained From Agency Exemplar Notes finger rolls, palms and feet MBIS Entry Panel Task / Test Value Latent # L5 MBIS Case # IDFSML224843 Evidence # L5 Lift # L5 Pattern Searched All patterns searched Positive Control Yes Auto LI WIN- Finger Date Searched 11/20/2022 Status Review / Verify Date Verified 11/20/2022 Idaho Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/20/2022 Date Verified 11/20/2022 WIN Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/20/2022 Date Verified 11/20/2022 Date Registered 11/20/2022 FBI Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/20/2022 Date Verified 11/21/2022 Date Registered 11/21/2022
Notes 11/20/2022: launched Remote LI to Cal DOJ, search did not return.

11/21/2022: launched a second Remote LI to Cal DOJ that did not return. Also launched two separate Remote_LI searches to Cal DOJ with only record designation 1 and only record designation 2- each individual search returned candidate lists, both lists verified.

11/22/2022: when compiling the MBIS documents, realized the two remote search lists appeared to be FBI numbers, indicating that those searches went to FBI rather than Cal DOJ. Launched another Remote LI to Cal DOJ on 11 / 22 / 2022- this search did not return in a timely manner, contacted NEC, who retried the search. No Remote_LI to Cal DOJ returned for this latent entry, killed all unreturned Remote_LI searches for L5 and launched a Remote_LI using L-5, see entry below.

11/28/2022 launched LLI in order to search against registered latents.

The first candidate on the list is L-5 of this case, no hit on all other candidates.

Result No Hit Page 3 of 5 000855

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 4 of 37
LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES

URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 11/20/2022 to 11/28/2022 Analyst searching MBIS (if Hailey Youngling different) Analyst Assigned Reviewed MBIS Tara Martinez Documents Date 11/28/2022 Task / Test Value Latent # L5 MBIS Case # IDFSML224843 Evidence # L-5 Lift # L-5 Pattern Searched All patterns searched Positive Control Yes Idaho Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/21/2022 Date Verified 11/21/2022 WIN Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/21/2022 Date Verified 11/21/2022 Date Registered 11/21/2022 FBI Rolled and Slapped Date Searched 11/21/2022 Date Verified 11/21/2022 Date Registered 11/21/2022 Notes Requested 30 candidates for Idaho, WIN and FBI. FBI search returned 20 candidates.

11/25/2022 due to issues with L5 not returning the Remote_LI to Cal DOJ, launched L-5 Remote_LI to Cal DOJ, candidate list verified on
11/25/2022.

11/28/2022 launched LLI in order to search against registered latents.

The first candidate on the list is L5 of this case, no hit on all other candidates.

Result No Hit Analyst searching MBIS (if Hailey Youngling different) Analyst Assigned Reviewed MBIS Tara Martinez Documents Date 11/28/2022 Latent Print Notes Panel Task / Test Value Notes L3 is a possible fabric impression and L4 is a possible shoe impression-not analyzed.

11/22/22: Ran III search on Jack Ducoeur (DOB ██████ (2000), Bethany Funke (DOB ██████ (2003) and Dylan Mortensen (DOB █████ (2003); no records found.

This is the first report. The report for L1, L2 and L6 will follow (assignment already started).

Page 4 of 5 000856

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 5 of 37
LATENT PRINT ANALYSIS NOTES

URN / Dept Case #: 22-M09903 Case: M2022-4843 Examiner: Tara Martinez Dates of analysis: 11/20/2022 to 11/28/2022 Comparison Table
MADISON MOGEN XANA KERNODLE ETHAN CHAPIN

L5 EXC INCE INCE

KAYLEE GONCALVES

L5 EXC

Page 5 of 5 000857

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 6 of 37
R. INDEX R. MIDDLE R. RING R. LITTLE

R. THUMB

22 - ΜΦ9903 22-11-0028 Mogen, Madison 이 Interdigital
11/17/2022 LE

R.

R. siap PALM
R.

000858

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 7 of 37 hel Right thumb Indet Interdigital Right Right slap Palm Right ر گرما 000859

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 8 of 37 ру
L. RING L. MIDDLE L. INDEX

L. THUMB

L. LITTLE

L. LITTLE

Interdigital
L.

L.Siap
L.

PALM

22-M89903 22-11-0028

Mogan, Madison 01 Clb 11/17/22 M2022-1843-272 pm ১४ 000860

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 9 of 37 Left left lett left Lett thumb / / little index middle ring little left interdigital left slap left palm 000861

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 10 of 37
L. FOOT

22-11-0028 10 Madison
11/17/22
M89903

Mogan,
- Clb 22
M2022-4843-27.3 ТM 11/22/22

112-2 000862

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 11 of 37 left foot left foot 000863

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 12 of 37 M
R. FOOT

22-11-4028 19 38 Madison
M00903

11/17/22 Mogen,
- 22 Ensweenew Wel ll eeee - hite 000864

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 13 of 37 hel RFock RFoot
NOT

= の の の 000865

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 14 of 37
MIDDLE L. INDEX L. THUMB

L.

L. LITTLE L. RING

Siap L L. Hand Kernodle, Xana
DOB ████ 02 L. PALM

22-M09903 22-11-0028

11/16/22 S.micke M2082-4843-06.1 The 11 2222 000866

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 15 of 37 L.Thumb L.Middle L.Index Ring L.little
L -

Palm L.Slap
L.

あのめり に WT1.JB-ENEN-GOUCM

000867

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 16 of 37
R. INDEX R. MIDDLE

R. THUMB

R. RING

R. LITTLE

Slap R.

R. Hand Kernodle, Xana 22-m09903 22-11-0028 R. PALM 11/16/22 L. Estridge M2202-4843-26.2 Thi 11 or DOB 2002 000868

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 17 of 37 Thunb Little Ring middle Index
R. R.

R. R

R.

BLAC 8

10 Palm
R.

slap
R.

४० S. - ENON-COSM

000869

22-M09903 # 5 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 18 of 37 2002 Xana 22-11-0028 ███
Kernodle, ███ DOB S.Micke
M09903

foot 11/10/22 Left-22 eenew-Ensh-Ege llit le ec 000870

22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 16 of 32 3rd floor bedroom-blood stains
BA: few small circular stains (less than Imm); majority are eliptical stains whose lower ends are on the rightside.

The higher end is on the left -side side,, with a smaller trail of blood extending from the end of the elipsis,, also from lower right to upper left (largest elipsis ~ 3mm widex widex long less less. than Imm wide)
1/9/23
BB: -primarily Circular stains, ranging in sre from less than Imm to ~ 4mm; distribution appears to be linear -Some eliptical stains, primarily oriented with the higher end on The nght side, The lower end on The left side (gravity) -one irregular stain, its orientation nearly strought up / down on the wall, slightly circular / oval at top of stain; inconsistent distribution of blood from top to bottom "
BC: -variety of shapes and sizes of stains; stain # 43 present in distribution numerous arcular stains, which appear to be in a Linear formation, which extends into the area marked BB;
some eliptical stains, primarily with the orientation pointing down (gravity) -numerous irregularly shaped stains, several of which are long and thin, which could have been caused by bloody hair moving.

against the wall; bed was against the wall in this area
BD: - over laps with stains labeled BC; lower portion of area of stains, closer to top of mattress largest stains appear to be volume of blood that flowed down wall (gravity) -numerous small cireular and eliptical stains present
BE: -numerous primarily circular stains, varying in size; marry in linear disth bution.

-some distribution non-linear " In upper right area, numerous smaller volume stains with a short area of flow (gravity)
BF: -primarily eliptical stains, distribution in a conical pattern, smaller end of cone at lower right, larger area of Cone higher some circular stains, whose distribution may be linear One larger stain, whose orientation nearly straught up / down.

that appears to flow down the wall I gravity) & numerous Smaller circular / orne stains whose volume appears to T 13 OF 29 be puiled down (gravity) 014941

22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 17 of 32 3rd floor bedroom-blood stains (cont.)

BF: (cont.) distribution of stains extends to underside of shelf mounted on the wall. Stains are circular, varying in size. Some distribution appears linear.

BG: -primarily aroular stains, varying in size; some distribution appears linear.

- Stain # 44 is approximately straight up / down; volume of blood that appears to flow down wall; appears to have disturbance to stain numerous irregular stains that appear smeared and / or made by a bloody object contacting the surface
BH: - Circular stains, varying in size, in approximate Incar distribution eliptical stains, some orientation up & to right, some left to right, and some downward and to night
- distribution of stains extends to underside of shelf mounted on the wall. Stains are Circular, varying in size. Some distribution appears linear. At least one stain appears eliptical.

BI: -varying sizes and shapes of stains Stains at # 45 are approximately straight up / down;
Volume of blood that appears to flow down wall; appears to hare disturbance to left stain
- varying sizes of eliptical stains, some pointing up and to right, some pointing downward and to right
- above top surface of bed, and betureen bed and bedside table.

BJ: -primanty circular stains, ranjing in size; some appear to be in linear distribution
- some eliptical stains, pointing down
• Stains at # 46 are both circular and eliptical
BR: circular stains, varying sizes; appear to be in Unear distribution
BL: Small round & eliptical stains
BM: primarily circular stains, of varying sizes, on ceiling above bed; varying distribution, including some that ██
appear Unear ██
mint 14 OF 29 WAth 014942

22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 18 of 32 1122 King Rd, MosCOW, ID 3rd floor E bedroom #hot to scale Bloodstains BA-BL
BE 01/09/235

BA

BC

BB BD

BED BG BF

78
BI BH

DESK

CLOSET

BJ

W لها

S

BK

Huy wunt
15 OF 29 WAR

014943

22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 19 of 32
Prepared by: J. Ayers
Date: 11/18/22 2 2nd floor windows 3 Living room IN wall un locked 4 west bedroom N wal Unlocked 5 east bedroom Swall locked 6 Kitchen Swall Unlocked 7 Kitchen wwal Unlocked 8 3rd floor Windows 9 10 hallway Nwall locked 11 west bedroom N wall Acunit in place, 12 hothing above it to block open space 13 blinds down to top of A Cunit 14 west bedroom sliding glass door unlocked 15 Cevidence tape broken 1556 to check.) 16 bathroom north wall unlocked 17 east bedroom south wall Unlocked 18 19 @ 1558 router on 2nd floor removed lay 20 Det. Talbott 21 22 1st floor windows 23 west bedroom North wall Unlocked 24 east bedroom Nortz wall locked 25 thy 26 mnt
27 TM

28 ke OF 29 014944

22-M09903 # 11 M2022-4843

MOSCOW POLICE DEPARTMENT Page 20 of 32
██████████ Presumptive Chemical Tests for Blood
Date: 11/11/2 ██████████ Lab Number: M2277-4843
Chemical Lot #: 10-TOLOA0920 H202-HP040920 Analyst (s): HOGAN Control (known blood) result: O-Tol POS: Blue / Green NEG: No immediate color change Control (known blood) result: Phenol POS: Pink circle results.) CONTROLS TESTED @ ~ 16000ST (
RESULTS COLLECTION

INCONCLUSIVE COLLECT NO COLLECTED

NEGATIVE COLLECTION

MARKER # POSITIVE CUTTING

OR GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF STAIN AND / OR SWAB ITEM

IDENTIFIER SURFACE, LOCATION BY

ISP D2 RED STAIN W / IRREGULAR EDERLS BETWEEN

NORTH WAR OF STAIRWAY

23 FLOOR 12

X

ISP D2 RED, SMAL, GRULAR STAIN, NORTH ないる

WAN OF STAIRWAY BETWEEN FOR

24 142 (EAST OF 23)

ISP D2 RED PRIP STAIN, HALF WALL OO

25 STAIRWAY BETWEEN